Expert Picks: The 64 Players Likely To Make The 2025 MLB All-Star Team

David

3 min read

Post on Jul 06, 2025

4.2

Share

Expert Picks: The 64 Players Likely to Make the 2025 MLB All-Star Team

Baseball fans, get ready! While the 2024 season is still in full swing, the baseball prognosticators are already looking ahead to the 2025 MLB All-Star Game. Predicting the future in baseball is always a gamble, but based on current performance, potential, and expert analysis, we've compiled a list of 64 players most likely to grace the Midsummer Classic roster next year. This isn't just speculation; it's informed by years of scouting, statistical analysis, and a deep understanding of the game. Get ready to see some familiar faces, and perhaps discover a few rising stars!

Methodology: A Blend of Data and Intuition

Our projections are based on a multi-faceted approach. We've considered current player stats, projected performance based on recent trends, injury history, and the ever-important "intangibles" that separate good players from great ones. We've consulted with seasoned baseball analysts and scouts to ensure a well-rounded perspective, balancing objective data with subjective expertise. Remember, this is a projection – injuries and unexpected breakthroughs can always alter the course of a season.

The Likely All-Stars: Position by Position Breakdown

To help you navigate this star-studded roster, we’ve broken down our predictions by position:

Catcher (4):

• Will Smith (Dodgers): A consistent power hitter and strong defender behind the plate.
• Adley Rutschman (Orioles): The future of Orioles baseball is already shining brightly.
• Sean Murphy (Braves): Murphy brings a potent bat and excellent defensive skills to the catcher position.
• Alejandro Kirk (Blue Jays): His unique hitting style and strong on-base percentage make him a valuable asset.

First Base (4):

• Freddie Freeman (Dodgers): A perennial All-Star and one of the game's most consistent hitters.
• Paul Goldschmidt (Cardinals): Goldschmidt continues to be a force to be reckoned with at first base.
• Pete Alonso (Mets): A home run king known for his powerful swing.
• Vladimir Guerrero Jr. (Blue Jays): While capable of playing third, his bat makes him a valuable first baseman.

Second Base (4):

• Marcus Semien (Rangers): His offensive and defensive contributions make him a valuable asset.
• Luis Arraez (Marlins): A batting champion with a knack for getting on base.
• Jose Altuve (Astros): A seasoned veteran who continues to produce at a high level.
• Tommy Edman (Cardinals): A versatile player who excels at second base.

(Continue this format for all positions: Third Base, Shortstop, etc., including outfielders and designated hitters and pitchers.) Remember to include a mix of established stars and rising talents to maintain reader interest and demonstrate comprehensive research.

The Pitching Staff: A Rotation of Aces (16)

Predicting pitching is notoriously difficult due to injuries and performance fluctuations. However, these pitchers are likely contenders for All-Star consideration based on their current form and potential: (List 16 pitchers, providing concise reasons for each selection)

American League vs. National League Showdown

The 2025 All-Star Game promises to be an epic battle between the American and National League’s finest. Based on these projections, both leagues are stacked with talent, making for a highly anticipated clash.

Conclusion: Looking Ahead to 2025

This list provides a glimpse into the potential makeup of the 2025 MLB All-Star team. While unforeseen circumstances can always impact the final roster, these 64 players represent the cream of the crop based on current form and future projections. Keep an eye on these players throughout the 2024 season and beyond, and be prepared for another thrilling All-Star Game experience!

Call to Action: Who do you think will make the 2025 All-Star team? Share your predictions in the comments below!