Contenders Or Pretenders? Evaluating Backup QBs For A 2024 NFL Playoff Bid

3 min read Post on May 27, 2025

Contenders or Pretenders? Evaluating Backup QBs for a 2024 NFL Playoff Bid

The NFL season is a marathon, not a sprint, and even the most robust starting quarterbacks are susceptible to injury. For teams harboring legitimate 2024 playoff aspirations, the quality of their backup quarterback is no longer a luxury – it's a necessity. This year, the difference between a successful season and a disappointing one could hinge on the performance of a number two. Let's dive into some key backup quarterbacks and assess whether they're contenders or pretenders in the race for a playoff spot.

The Elite Few: Proven Commodities

A handful of teams boast backup quarterbacks who could seamlessly step in and maintain a high level of play. These aren't just game managers; they're capable of leading their teams to victory.

Brock Purdy (San Francisco 49ers): Purdy's surprising late-season surge in 2022 catapulted him into the spotlight. While recovering from injury, his potential remains incredibly high. If healthy, he's a serious asset for the 49ers' playoff hopes. His performance last season proved he's not just a pretender, but a legitimate threat.
Cooper Rush (Dallas Cowboys): Rush has consistently shown reliability and competency when called upon. While he won't wow you with spectacular plays, his steady hand and game management skills make him a valuable asset to Dallas. His experience is a considerable advantage.
Taylor Heinicke (Atlanta Falcons): Heinicke's ability to extend plays with his legs and make crucial throws under pressure makes him a dangerous wildcard. He's proven capable of leading a team to success, providing a solid safety net for the Falcons.

The Intriguing Middle Ground: Potential vs. Experience

This group presents a fascinating mix of potential and proven ability. Their performance will significantly influence their team's playoff chances.

Desmond Ridder (Atlanta Falcons): Ridder's potential is undeniable, but he needs more game experience to solidify his status. His performance in 2023 will be pivotal for the Falcons’ playoff hopes. He’s undoubtedly a key player to watch this season.
Will Grier (Dallas Cowboys): Grier is an intriguing prospect, but his lack of significant NFL experience makes him a bit of a question mark. The Cowboys’ coaching staff will need to nurture his talent effectively.
Gardner Minshew (Indianapolis Colts): Minshew has shown flashes of brilliance, but consistency remains an issue. His performance will determine whether he's a valuable asset or a liability for the Colts' postseason aspirations.

The Question Marks: High Risk, High Reward?

Several teams rely on backup quarterbacks with limited experience. These players present a high-risk, high-reward scenario. Their performance could drastically impact their team’s season.

Undrafted Free Agents and Rookies: Many teams rely heavily on young, inexperienced quarterbacks, hoping for a late-season gem. This strategy is a gamble and makes their playoff prospects uncertain. The development of these players is something to monitor closely throughout the season.

The Impact on Playoff Odds

The impact of a strong backup quarterback on playoff odds is significant. A capable backup can absorb the pressure when the starter falters, preventing a season derailment. Teams with proven backups are significantly better positioned for a deep playoff run. Consider the impact of injuries on last season's playoff race - it clearly demonstrates the importance of a reliable understudy.

Conclusion: Preparation is Key

The 2024 NFL season will be a test of depth and resilience. Teams that invested wisely in their backup quarterback positions will be significantly better equipped to handle adversity and pursue playoff glory. The performance of these quarterbacks will be a crucial storyline to watch as the season unfolds. Who will emerge as a contender and who will fall short? Only time will tell. Stay tuned for updates throughout the season!