Ranking The Best Backup QBs: Who Could Spearhead A 2024 NFL Playoff Push?

3 min read Post on May 27, 2025

Ranking the Best Backup QBs: Who Could Spearhead a 2024 NFL Playoff Push?

The NFL is a league of razor-thin margins. One injury to a star quarterback can derail an entire season, transforming a Super Bowl contender into a also-ran. That's why the quality of a backup quarterback is paramount. But who among the league's second-stringers has the potential to not just fill in, but actually lead a team to a playoff berth in 2024? Let's rank the top contenders.

The Top Tier: Proven Performers

This group isn't just capable of managing games; they've demonstrated the ability to win them. These quarterbacks possess starting-caliber talent, waiting for their opportunity to shine.

Brock Purdy (San Francisco 49ers): Purdy's late-season surge in 2022, culminating in a playoff run before injury, catapulted him to the top of this list. His accuracy, decision-making, and composure under pressure are exceptional for a young player. While his health is a question mark, a healthy Purdy is a legitimate playoff threat.
Cooper Rush (Dallas Cowboys): A consistent performer, Rush has proven his ability to keep the Cowboys competitive whenever called upon. His game isn't flashy, but he manages the offense effectively and avoids costly turnovers – a crucial trait for any backup. His experience within the Cowboys' system is a significant asset.

The Contenders: High Potential, Unproven at Scale

This next tier features quarterbacks with impressive talent, but they haven't yet had the opportunity to prove themselves over an extended period in a starting role.

Gardner Minshew (Indianapolis Colts): Minshew boasts a unique skillset and a fearless playing style. He's shown flashes of brilliance, but consistency has been an issue. A strong preseason could solidify his position in this ranking.
Bailey Zappe (New England Patriots): Zappe's performance in limited action has been encouraging. His arm strength and accuracy are noteworthy, but he needs more reps to demonstrate his ability to consistently handle the pressures of a starting role.

The Dark Horses: Wildcard Options

These quarterbacks might not be on many radars, but they possess the potential for a breakout season if given the chance.

Jordan Love (Green Bay Packers): Love's time in Green Bay has been largely spent learning behind Aaron Rodgers. Now, with Rodgers gone, the opportunity is his. Success or failure will largely define his place in the NFL landscape and potentially elevate him in future rankings.
Will Grier (Dallas Cowboys): While less heralded than Rush, Grier provides valuable depth for the Cowboys. His experience, although limited, within a winning system could be enough for him to step in if needed.

Factors Beyond Talent: The Importance of System Fit

It's crucial to remember that a backup quarterback's success hinges not only on individual talent but also on system fit. A quarterback who thrives in a structured, run-heavy offense might struggle in a more complex, pass-heavy scheme. The coaching staff's ability to adapt the game plan to the backup's strengths is crucial.

Conclusion: Uncertainty and Opportunity

Predicting who will lead a playoff push is always challenging. However, based on past performances and potential, the quarterbacks listed above present the best chances for their teams in 2024 should the unfortunate happen. The upcoming season will undoubtedly reveal who truly has the mettle to rise to the occasion. Keep an eye on these players – their performances could redefine the narrative of the 2024 NFL season.

Call to Action: Who do you think is the best backup quarterback in the NFL? Let us know in the comments below!