Why Jensen Ackles' 35% Rotten Tomatoes Show Needs A Second Season

David

3 min read

Post on Sep 04, 2025

4.6

Share

Why Jensen Ackles' 35% Rotten Tomatoes Show The Winchesters Needs a Second Season

Jensen Ackles, beloved by fans for his portrayal of Dean Winchester in Supernatural, took a gamble with The Winchesters, a prequel series exploring the origin story of his character's parents. While the critical reception, reflected in a disappointing 35% Rotten Tomatoes score, might seem damning, arguing for a second season isn't about ignoring the flaws; it's about recognizing the potential and the passionate fanbase that deserves a proper conclusion.

The show, focusing on John and Mary Winchester's romance amidst a backdrop of monster hunting, faced an uphill battle. Released on The CW, a network struggling with declining viewership and significant budget cuts, The Winchesters never had the marketing push or consistent scheduling needed to truly capture a wide audience. This, arguably, is a larger problem than the show's inherent qualities.

What Went Wrong (and Why it Doesn't Matter Entirely)?

• The CW's Uncertain Future: The network's instability significantly impacted The Winchesters' visibility. A lack of consistent promotional efforts and a confusing release schedule hampered its ability to gain traction. This isn't a reflection of the show's quality, but rather a symptom of a larger network-wide issue.

• High Expectations & Supernatural's Legacy: Stepping into the shadow of Supernatural, arguably one of the most successful CW shows of all time, was a daunting task. The expectation to replicate Supernatural's success, both critically and commercially, was perhaps unrealistic from the outset. However, this doesn't negate The Winchesters' strengths.

• Narrative Pace and Character Development: Critics often pointed to a somewhat uneven pacing and underdeveloped supporting characters. While valid criticisms, these are issues that can be addressed and improved upon in a potential second season with adjusted production timelines and a refined creative direction.

Why a Second Season is Justified:

• Dedicated Fanbase: Despite the low Rotten Tomatoes score, The Winchesters boasts a passionate and dedicated fanbase actively campaigning for renewal. This dedicated viewership, often overlooked in purely ratings-driven decisions, represents a significant source of potential growth and loyalty. Their unwavering support should not be underestimated.

• Untapped Potential: The show's premise, exploring the untold stories of iconic characters from Supernatural, holds immense potential for further development. A second season could refine the narrative pacing, deepen character arcs, and explore the mythology further. The groundwork is there; it just needs the opportunity to flourish.

• Opportunity for Growth: Constructive criticism should be seen as an opportunity for improvement, not a death sentence. A second season would allow the creative team to learn from the first season's shortcomings and deliver a more refined and engaging viewing experience.

The Verdict: Give The Winchesters a Chance

While The Winchesters' 35% Rotten Tomatoes score is certainly a cause for concern, it's not the sole indicator of its worth. Considering the factors outside the show's direct control, such as The CW's precarious position and the weight of Supernatural's legacy, a fair assessment requires looking beyond a single metric. The dedicated fanbase, the untapped potential within the story, and the opportunity for significant growth all point towards a deserving second season. Let's not let a flawed first season overshadow the potential for a truly compelling story. The Winchesters deserve a second chance.

What are your thoughts? Do you think The Winchesters deserves a second season? Share your opinions in the comments below!