Who Will The Yankees Trade For? Exploring Third Base Trade Scenarios

David

3 min read

Post on Jul 04, 2025

4.9

Share

Who Will the Yankees Trade For? Exploring Third Base Trade Scenarios

The New York Yankees' quest for a starting third baseman is one of the hottest topics in baseball this offseason. After a season of inconsistent performance at the hot corner, General Manager Brian Cashman is under pressure to bolster the lineup. But who will the Yankees trade for? Let's delve into some potential trade scenarios and explore the players who could be donning pinstripes come Opening Day.

The Yankees' need for a reliable third baseman is undeniable. While Josh Donaldson provided veteran experience, his performance dipped significantly in 2023. This leaves a gaping hole in their infield, a hole that needs filling to contend for a World Series title. The front office has made it clear they're actively seeking upgrades, leading to speculation about potential trades.

Potential Trade Targets:

Several players are being linked with a move to the Bronx. Let's examine some of the most likely candidates:

1. Nolan Arenado (St. Louis Cardinals): While a seemingly monumental task, Arenado's name continues to surface in trade rumors. His defensive prowess is undeniable, and his bat, while not quite at its peak, still boasts significant power. However, trading for Arenado would require a significant prospect package, likely including some of the Yankees' top young talent. The Cardinals’ high asking price presents a significant hurdle for the Yankees.

2. Jeimer Candelario (Washington Nationals): A more affordable option, Candelario provides a solid bat and decent defense. He's a switch-hitter, offering flexibility to the Yankees' lineup. His trade value is considerably lower than Arenado’s, potentially making him a more realistic target. The Nationals, looking to rebuild, might be willing to part with him for a smaller package of prospects.

3. Eduardo Escobar (New York Mets): An intriguing intra-divisional trade possibility, Escobar brings experience and a strong bat. The Mets, also undergoing a roster reshaping, could be open to dealing him. This scenario offers a lower-risk, lower-reward alternative to acquiring a higher-profile player. However, the Mets may prioritize keeping Escobar within the division unless the return is highly favorable.

4. Other Possibilities: The Yankees' front office is known for its strategic approach, and they might surprise fans with an unexpected acquisition. Keep an eye on players like Gio Urshela (currently with the Angels) or even exploring a free agent signing if a favorable trade isn't available.

The Prospect Cost:

Any trade for a starting third baseman will involve parting with valuable prospects. The Yankees' farm system, while not as deep as some others, still possesses talented young players. The exact players included in any deal will depend heavily on the target and the asking price. Expect a mix of high-ceiling prospects and potentially some lower-level talent to sweeten the pot.

The Bottom Line:

The Yankees' search for a third baseman is far from over. The coming weeks will be crucial in determining their strategy. While Arenado represents a potential blockbuster, the more realistic scenario might involve acquiring a player like Candelario or exploring other less-discussed possibilities. The Yankees need to find the right balance between acquiring a significant upgrade and preserving the future of their organization. Stay tuned as the Hot Stove season heats up!

Keywords: Yankees trade, third baseman, MLB trade rumors, Yankees offseason, Nolan Arenado, Jeimer Candelario, Eduardo Escobar, baseball trade, NY Yankees prospects, Josh Donaldson, Major League Baseball