Which Team Wins The Post-Ohtani MLB Offseason? Jays, Giants, Cubs, Or Angels?

David

3 min read

Post on Aug 09, 2025

4.0

Share

Which Team Wins the Post-Ohtani MLB Offseason? Jays, Giants, Cubs, or Angels?

The 2023 MLB offseason was undeniably dominated by Shohei Ohtani's free agency. His eventual signing with the Los Angeles Angels sent shockwaves through the league, but the real question now is: who emerges as the true winner of the post-Ohtani offseason scramble? While the Angels secured the biggest prize, their success hinges on much more than just one player. Let's break down the contenders: the Toronto Blue Jays, the San Francisco Giants, the Chicago Cubs, and, of course, the Angels themselves.

The Los Angeles Angels: A Risky Gamble?

Landing Shohei Ohtani is undoubtedly a massive win for the Angels. They've addressed their biggest need – a frontline superstar – and injected a much-needed dose of excitement into their franchise. However, their success is far from guaranteed. Ohtani's presence alone doesn't automatically translate into a World Series appearance. The Angels need to solidify their supporting cast, improve their pitching depth, and, crucially, ensure Ohtani's health throughout the season. Their offseason moves beyond Ohtani will ultimately determine their true standing. Did they do enough? Only time will tell.

The Toronto Blue Jays: Steady Improvement?

The Blue Jays quietly had a strong offseason, focusing on bolstering their pitching rotation and adding depth to their lineup. While they didn't land a singular superstar like Ohtani, their strategic acquisitions point towards a team committed to consistent improvement. Their approach is less flashy, but potentially more sustainable. This strategy minimizes risk and positions them for sustained contention. Their improved pitching staff, alongside an already potent offense, makes them a serious contender in the AL East.

The San Francisco Giants: A Rebuild in Progress?

The Giants' offseason was more of a rebuild than a dramatic overhaul. They focused on adding young talent and addressing specific needs within their roster. This long-term approach may not yield immediate results, but it sets the foundation for future success. While they might not be contenders in 2024, their strategy shows a thoughtful and sustainable plan for long-term competitiveness. Their focus on developing their farm system could pay off handsomely in the coming years.

The Chicago Cubs: Building Momentum?

Similar to the Giants, the Cubs' offseason signaled a team building towards the future. They made key additions to solidify their young core, creating a promising foundation for future success. While a playoff appearance in 2024 is a possibility, their primary goal is long-term growth. Their approach mirrors the Giants, focusing on sustainable development over immediate gratification. This measured approach is a smart strategy for a franchise aiming for sustained success.

The Verdict: No Clear Winner (Yet)

Determining the "winner" of the post-Ohtani offseason is premature. While the Angels made the splashiest move, their success depends heavily on factors beyond just Ohtani's performance. The Blue Jays, Giants, and Cubs each took different approaches, prioritizing either immediate contention or long-term growth. The true winner will be determined not by the offseason moves alone, but by how these teams perform on the field in the coming season. The 2024 MLB season will be crucial in determining which team's strategy proved most effective.

What are your predictions for the 2024 MLB season? Share your thoughts in the comments below!