Which Backup Quarterbacks Could Surprise In The 2024 NFL Playoffs? A Tiered Ranking

David

3 min read

Post on Jun 06, 2025

4.2

Share

Which Backup Quarterbacks Could Surprise in the 2024 NFL Playoffs? A Tiered Ranking

The NFL playoffs are a crucible, forging heroes and shattering reputations in equal measure. While star quarterbacks often steal the show, the unexpected rise of a backup signal-caller can dramatically shift the postseason landscape. With the 2024 season looming, let's delve into the potential surprise packages lurking on the bench, tiered by their likelihood of making a significant impact.

Tier 1: The Sleepers with Starting Potential

This tier features quarterbacks who've shown flashes of brilliance in limited action and possess the talent to lead a team deep into the playoffs should the starter falter.

• Brock Purdy (San Francisco 49ers): Purdy's late-season surge in 2022 silenced many doubters. While his recovery from elbow surgery remains a key question mark, his arm talent and composure are undeniable. If healthy, he’s a legitimate threat to take over and lead the Niners on another playoff run. His performance will hinge on his recovery and the team's overall health.

• Desmond Ridder (Atlanta Falcons): Ridder showed encouraging signs as a starter towards the end of last season. While he still needs to refine his consistency, his athleticism and leadership qualities could make him a dangerous wildcard if called upon. The Falcons’ improved roster only enhances his potential impact.

Tier 2: The Game Managers with Upside

These quarterbacks might not possess the same ceiling as Tier 1, but they're reliable game managers capable of winning games with efficient play and smart decision-making.

• Cooper Rush (Dallas Cowboys): Rush has proven himself capable of keeping the Cowboys competitive in Dak Prescott's absence. His experience and familiarity with the offense make him a valuable asset, though his upside is limited compared to the previous tier.

• Taylor Heinicke (Atlanta Falcons): A veteran with playoff experience, Heinicke provides a steady hand if needed. His knowledge of the game and ability to manage clock situations could prove invaluable in crunch time.

Tier 3: The Wildcards

This category encompasses quarterbacks with less proven track records but possessing enough talent to make an impact under the right circumstances. Their performance would heavily depend on several factors, including the team’s offensive scheme and the nature of any injury that propels them into the spotlight.

• Jordan Love (Green Bay Packers): After years backing up Aaron Rodgers, Love finally got his chance as the starter. His potential is high but his consistency and experience remain to be seen. If he can find success in the regular season, he moves up this ranking.

• Malik Willis (Tennessee Titans): Willis's raw talent is undeniable, but he needs significant improvement in decision-making and consistency before he can be considered a true playoff threat. His presence, however, indicates the Titans are preparing for a potential quarterback shift.

Factors Influencing Backup Success

Several elements beyond individual talent influence a backup quarterback's playoff performance:

• Offensive Line Strength: A strong offensive line protects the quarterback and allows for consistent offensive production, crucial for backup success.
• Offensive Scheme: A simpler, more run-oriented scheme can lessen the burden on a backup QB, minimizing mistakes.
• Coaching Staff: Effective coaching can adapt to the backup's strengths and mitigate their weaknesses.
• Team Chemistry: Strong team cohesion can help a backup QB settle in quickly and maintain morale.

Conclusion: Uncertainty Reigns

Predicting playoff performance is always a challenge, and the role of the backup quarterback is particularly unpredictable. While some backups seem primed for a breakout performance, others represent more of a gamble. Keep your eye on these quarterbacks throughout the regular season—their performances will significantly impact our understanding of their playoff potential. Which of these backups do you think has the best chance to shine? Let us know in the comments below!