Which Backup QB Could Steal The Show? 2024 NFL Playoff Contender Ranking

David

3 min read

Post on Sep 10, 2025

4.2

Share

Which Backup QB Could Steal the Show? 2024 NFL Playoff Contender Ranking

The 2024 NFL season is shaping up to be a nail-biter, with several teams vying for the coveted playoff spots. But what happens when the starting quarterback goes down? The fate of many contenders might rest on the shoulders of their backup quarterbacks. This year, the depth at the quarterback position varies wildly, impacting the overall playoff predictions. Let's dive into a ranking of playoff contenders, considering the potential impact of their backup QBs.

Methodology: This ranking considers team strength, projected starting quarterback performance, the quality of the backup quarterback, and overall team depth. While predicting the future is impossible, we've analyzed current rosters and preseason projections to offer a reasoned assessment.

Tier 1: Contenders with Strong Backup QB Depth

These teams boast backups capable of stepping in and maintaining a high level of play, minimizing the impact of a starting QB injury.

1. Kansas City Chiefs: While Patrick Mahomes is arguably the league's best, the Chiefs have shown a commitment to developing quality backup QBs. Their current backup possesses the potential to keep the offense humming should Mahomes face injury. This strong backup significantly boosts their playoff chances.

2. Philadelphia Eagles: Jalen Hurts' health is paramount to the Eagles' success. However, their backup QB situation is significantly improved from last year, giving them a much higher degree of confidence in maintaining their offensive firepower. A reliable backup minimizes risk in a fiercely competitive NFC.

3. Buffalo Bills: Josh Allen's immense talent is undeniable, but the Bills have invested in a capable backup who could keep them competitive even in his absence. Their overall roster strength further solidifies their playoff prospects, even with QB uncertainty. This is a team built for a deep playoff run, regardless of injury concerns.

Tier 2: Contenders with Moderate Backup QB Depth

These teams have decent backups, but a starting quarterback injury could significantly impact their playoff chances.

4. Cincinnati Bengals: Joe Burrow's health is crucial. Their backup, while competent, may not possess the same ceiling. The Bengals' success largely hinges on Burrow's ability to stay healthy.

5. San Francisco 49ers: The 49ers' situation is unique. Their backup is experienced but might not replicate the success of their high-powered offense. Their playoff hopes depend heavily on remaining injury-free at the QB position.

6. Dallas Cowboys: The Cowboys have a solid backup, but a prolonged absence of their starting QB could create challenges. Their defensive strength could help mitigate some of this risk, but not completely. This is a team that needs its starting QB to stay healthy to compete for a championship.

Tier 3: Contenders with Questionable Backup QB Depth

For these teams, a starting quarterback injury could be catastrophic.

7. Baltimore Ravens: Lamar Jackson's injury history is a cause for concern. Their backup situation raises questions about their ability to maintain their offensive potency. Their playoff potential is heavily reliant on Jackson's health.

The Wildcard: Unexpected Performances

It's crucial to remember that backup quarterbacks can sometimes exceed expectations. A lesser-known player could unexpectedly emerge, dramatically changing a team's playoff trajectory. This unpredictability adds to the excitement and competitiveness of the NFL season.

Conclusion:

The 2024 NFL season will likely hinge on quarterback health more than ever. While some teams are well-positioned to handle injuries at the position, others face significant risk. Keeping an eye on backup QB performance throughout the season will be essential for accurate playoff predictions. Which backup QB will rise to the occasion and steal the show? Only time will tell. Stay tuned!

Call to Action: What are your predictions for this year's playoffs? Share your thoughts in the comments below!