Was Passing On Bregman A Mistake For The Red Sox? Boston Source Weighs In

David

3 min read

Post on Jul 07, 2025

4.5

Share

Was Passing on Bregman a Mistake for the Red Sox? Boston Source Weighs In

The Boston Red Sox have a history of both shrewd drafting and perplexing misses. While they've cultivated stars like Rafael Devers and Xander Bogaerts, a lingering question among fans continues to haunt Fenway Park: was passing on Alex Bregman in the 2015 MLB Draft a monumental error? A recent in-depth analysis from a prominent Boston source suggests the answer might be a resounding yes.

The 2015 draft saw the Red Sox select Andrew Benintendi with the seventh overall pick, a decision met with mixed reactions at the time. However, the Houston Astros selected Alex Bregman just a few picks later, a pick that has since become the stuff of legend. Bregman, a consistent All-Star and key component of the Astros' recent success, presents a stark contrast to the Red Sox's recent struggles at the hot corner.

The Benintendi Era and Its Aftermath:

Andrew Benintendi certainly contributed positively to the Red Sox during his time in Boston, providing impactful moments and showcasing considerable talent. However, his career trajectory ultimately didn't reach the heights many predicted, including that of a perennial All-Star. His departure from Boston left a void that, arguably, Bregman could have filled. This raises a crucial question: could the Red Sox have achieved greater success with Bregman in their lineup?

A Boston Source's Perspective:

A recent article in the Boston Globe delves into this very question, examining the Red Sox's scouting reports from 2015 and comparing Benintendi's and Bregman's subsequent career performances. The article, written by [insert name of Globe writer if known, otherwise omit this sentence], highlights the perceived risk-aversion in the Red Sox's draft strategy, potentially costing them a generational talent. The analysis suggests that while Benintendi was a solid prospect, Bregman's superior all-around game and consistent performance over the years make the Red Sox's decision appear increasingly questionable in hindsight.

Beyond the Stats: A Deeper Look:

The debate extends beyond simple statistics. Bregman’s leadership qualities, clutch hitting, and overall impact on a team are undeniable assets. The Red Sox have consistently searched for that type of player, and many believe Bregman perfectly fits the profile. The article also explores the impact such a decision could have had on the team's overall chemistry and playoff performance over the years.

What Does the Future Hold?

While we can only speculate about what could have been, the question remains highly relevant. The Red Sox's current struggles at third base underscore the importance of drafting and developing elite talent. This incident serves as a critical lesson for future drafting strategies, emphasizing the need for a more comprehensive evaluation process that accounts for both immediate potential and long-term impact. The Red Sox need to learn from past mistakes to build a sustainable winning franchise.

Call to Action: What are your thoughts? Was passing on Bregman a mistake? Share your opinions in the comments below! And be sure to read the full Boston Globe article for a more in-depth analysis. [Link to Boston Globe article - if available]

Keywords: Red Sox, Alex Bregman, Andrew Benintendi, 2015 MLB Draft, Boston Red Sox draft, MLB draft analysis, baseball draft, Fenway Park, baseball scouting, Red Sox prospects, Boston Globe, MLB news