Understudy To Superstar: Ranking NFL Backup Quarterbacks For 2024 Playoff Success

David

3 min read

Post on Jul 18, 2025

4.2

Share

Understudy to Superstar: Ranking NFL Backup Quarterbacks for 2024 Playoff Success

The NFL playoffs are a crucible. One injury, one unexpected slump from a star quarterback, and a season's hopes can crumble. That's why the quality of a backup quarterback is paramount. This year, some teams boast exceptionally capable understudies, while others face a more precarious situation. Let's rank the NFL's backup quarterbacks heading into the 2024 season, assessing their potential to deliver playoff success should fate call.

Methodology: Our ranking considers a combination of factors: past performance (both starting and backup experience), skillset, familiarity with the team's system, and overall perceived readiness. It's a subjective assessment, acknowledging the unpredictable nature of injuries and in-game performance.

Tier 1: The Ready-Made Replacements

This tier represents quarterbacks who could seamlessly step in and maintain a high level of play. These aren't just game managers; they're potential playoff heroes.

1. Brock Purdy (San Francisco 49ers): Purdy's unexpected late-season surge in 2022 proved his ability to lead an offense at a championship level. While his injury history is a slight concern, his talent and familiarity with Kyle Shanahan's system solidify his position at the top. He's not just a backup; he's a potential franchise quarterback.

2. Jordan Love (Green Bay Packers): Love finally gets his chance after years of learning behind Aaron Rodgers. His preseason performances have hinted at significant potential, and the Packers' offensive system should allow him to thrive. He's faced criticism, but the opportunity to prove doubters wrong is his for the taking. [Link to an article about Jordan Love's preseason performance].

3. Cooper Rush (Dallas Cowboys): A consistent performer, Rush has proven he can win games in the NFL. While not flashy, his reliability and understanding of the Cowboys’ system make him a valuable asset.

Tier 2: Capable, but with Question Marks

This tier includes quarterbacks with some starting experience, but with less consistent success or less familiarity with their team's offensive scheme.

4. Desmond Ridder (Atlanta Falcons): Ridder showed flashes of brilliance in his limited starts last year. His mobility and arm talent are evident, but consistency remains a question mark. [Link to an article about Desmond Ridder's 2023 Season].

5. Will Levis (Tennessee Titans): A high draft pick, Levis has the physical tools to succeed. However, he lacks significant NFL game experience, making his readiness uncertain.

Tier 3: High-Risk, High-Reward (or Just High-Risk)

These backups present a gamble. Their potential is undeniable, but their reliability in a high-pressure playoff scenario remains a considerable concern.

6. Bailey Zappe (New England Patriots): Zappe’s surprising performance in limited action last year showed some promise, but his consistency is unproven.

7. Most other NFL backup quarterbacks: The remaining backups fall into this category. While some might possess talent, they lack the experience and proven track record to inspire significant confidence in a playoff setting.

Conclusion: The Importance of Backup QB Depth

The 2024 NFL season highlights the crucial role of capable backup quarterbacks. Teams with strong backups enter the playoffs with significantly improved odds of success. While predicting the future is impossible, the quarterbacks listed in Tier 1 provide the greatest assurance should the starter falter. This ranking serves as a reminder of the depth needed to compete for a Super Bowl. The health of your starting quarterback is vital, but a reliable backup is the ultimate insurance policy.