Understudy To Superstar: Ranking Backup QBs For A 2024 NFL Playoff Bid

David

3 min read

Post on Jul 14, 2025

4.6

Share

Understudy to Superstar: Ranking Backup QBs for a 2024 NFL Playoff Bid

The NFL is a league of razor-thin margins. One injury, one unexpected slump, can derail even the most promising season. For teams aiming for a 2024 playoff berth, the quality of their backup quarterback is no longer a luxury, but a crucial factor determining postseason success. This year, the depth chart behind some of the league's biggest names is surprisingly robust, offering intriguing possibilities and potential pitfalls. Let's rank some of the top backup quarterbacks who could be key players in their team's playoff push.

Methodology: This ranking considers a combination of factors: previous NFL experience, recent performance (including preseason games), perceived fit within their team's offensive system, and overall potential to step in and maintain a winning formula. It’s important to remember this is a projection based on available information; unforeseen circumstances could significantly alter the landscape.

Tier 1: The Ready-to-Roll Reserves

1. Brock Purdy (San Francisco 49ers): Purdy's improbable playoff run in 2022 catapults him to the top of this list. While recovering from an elbow injury, his performance last year demonstrated a poise and accuracy beyond his experience. If healthy, he’s arguably the best backup quarterback in the league. His familiarity with Kyle Shanahan's offense is a massive advantage.

2. Cooper Rush (Dallas Cowboys): A consistent performer, Rush has proven he can win games in the NFL, filling in admirably for Dak Prescott in the past. His experience within the Cowboys' system and his steady demeanor make him a valuable asset.

3. Gardner Minshew (Indianapolis Colts): Minshew has shown flashes of brilliance throughout his career. His arm talent and ability to extend plays could make him a surprisingly effective starter if called upon. His fit within the Colts' offense remains to be seen, however.

Tier 2: Promising Prospects with Potential

1. Malik Willis (Tennessee Titans): Willis possesses exceptional athleticism and a strong arm, but his accuracy and decision-making need refinement. A year of learning behind veteran Ryan Tannehill could prove invaluable. His upside is high, but his readiness for a significant starting role is still a question mark.

2. Desmond Ridder (Atlanta Falcons): Ridder showed improvement towards the end of last season, giving the Falcons hope. His development will be crucial for Atlanta's playoff hopes, as his performance will heavily influence the team's ability to overcome a potential injury to their starting quarterback.

Tier 3: Unproven Commodities

This tier includes players with limited NFL experience or those whose performances have yet to demonstrate consistent reliability as potential starters. While they offer potential, their readiness for a playoff push is significantly lower than the quarterbacks in the higher tiers.

The Wildcard Factor: Preseason Performance

Preseason games will be crucial in solidifying these rankings. Strong performances from backups could elevate their standing, while poor showings could expose vulnerabilities. Keep an eye on these developments as the NFL season approaches.

Conclusion: The 2024 NFL playoff race will likely hinge on more than just the starting quarterbacks. The quality of backup quarterbacks will play a significant, perhaps even decisive, role. Teams with strong backups will be better equipped to navigate injuries and maintain their playoff aspirations throughout the season. This ranking is just a snapshot; the landscape could change drastically as the season progresses. Stay tuned for further updates as we get closer to the regular season kickoff.

Call to Action: Who do you think is the most underrated backup QB heading into the 2024 season? Share your thoughts in the comments below!