Understanding The New Roughing The Passer Rules: An Explanation From Mike Pereira

David

3 min read

Post on Aug 31, 2025

4.3

Share

Understanding the New Roughing the Passer Rules: An Explanation from Mike Pereira

The NFL's officiating has always been a hot-button topic, and few calls spark more debate than "roughing the passer." The 2023 season saw significant changes to the rule, leading to confusion and controversy. To shed light on these alterations, we turn to a leading authority: former NFL vice president of officiating, Mike Pereira. His insights provide much-needed clarity on what constitutes a foul under the new guidelines.

The 2023 Rule Changes: A Necessary Clarification

The NFL's emphasis on player safety is paramount. This year's revisions to the roughing the passer rule aim to better protect quarterbacks from unnecessary and dangerous hits. However, the implementation has been, at times, inconsistent, resulting in frustration among players, coaches, and fans alike. Pereira, known for his insightful commentary and detailed explanations, helps dissect the complexities of these adjustments.

Key Changes Explained by Mike Pereira:

According to Pereira, the core issue lies in the interpretation of "unnecessary roughness." The rulebook strives to differentiate between forceful, but legal, tackles and those that constitute dangerous or illegal contact. Pereira highlights several key aspects of the revised rule:

• Emphasis on the "Landing": Pereira stresses the importance of how a defender lands on a quarterback. A hit that results in a defender falling on the quarterback, even if the initial contact is legal, is now more likely to be flagged. This is a critical departure from previous interpretations.

• Helmet-to-Helmet Contact Remains Prohibited: While the focus has shifted slightly, helmet-to-helmet contact remains strictly prohibited and will result in a penalty regardless of the circumstances. This continues to be a major point of emphasis for officials.

• The "Burying" of the Quarterback: Pereira uses the term "burying" to describe a defender falling onto the quarterback, effectively trapping them under their weight. This action is almost always flagged as a foul, highlighting the league's commitment to player safety.

• The "Lunge" and "Unnecessary Force": The rule aims to penalize defenders who launch themselves at the quarterback with excessive force, even if contact is made legally. This addresses the problem of unnecessary and violent hits that may not be deemed illegal under previous interpretations.

Why the Inconsistency?

Even with Pereira's detailed explanations, the inconsistency in officiating remains a challenge. The subjective nature of judging "unnecessary roughness" makes it difficult to apply the rule uniformly across all games. The high-speed nature of the game and the split-second decisions officials must make contribute to this inconsistency.

Moving Forward: Improving Consistency in Officiating

Pereira suggests that improved training and clearer communication between officials are essential to achieving greater consistency. The NFL is actively working on this, aiming to provide officials with more effective tools and resources to properly enforce the new rules. The use of video review and further analysis of questionable calls may also play a role in improving the application of the rule.

Conclusion: Understanding the nuances of the new roughing the passer rules requires careful consideration of the points highlighted by Pereira. While the intent is clear – to protect quarterbacks – the implementation remains a work in progress. Continued dialogue and refinement of both the rule and its application are crucial for maintaining fair play and ensuring player safety within the NFL. The league's dedication to this process offers hope for clearer and more consistent officiating in the future. Let's see how this evolving situation plays out throughout the remainder of the season.