Tyreek Hill's Top 5 QBs: A Controversial List Excludes Tua

David

3 min read

Post on May 08, 2025

4.3

Share

Tyreek Hill's Top 5 QBs: A Controversial List Excludes Tua – And Fans Are Furious!

Tyreek Hill, the electrifying wide receiver for the Miami Dolphins, recently stirred the pot with his "Top 5 QBs of All Time" list, a ranking that notably excluded his current teammate, Tua Tagovailoa. The revelation, shared on his podcast, has ignited a firestorm of debate among NFL fans and analysts alike. The omission of Tagovailoa, a player Hill has publicly praised in the past, is particularly striking, prompting questions about Hill's criteria and the underlying dynamics within the Dolphins organization.

This seemingly innocuous ranking has become a major talking point, highlighting the complexities of player relationships and the ever-present scrutiny in the NFL. Let's delve into Hill's controversial list and unpack the reasons behind the ensuing uproar.

Hill's Top 5 (and the Missing Tua):

While the exact order fluctuated slightly across different platforms, Hill's list consistently featured these quarterbacks:

1. Patrick Mahomes: This choice comes as no surprise. Hill's prolific years with Mahomes in Kansas City cemented their connection as one of the most dynamic quarterback-receiver duos in NFL history. Their chemistry on the field is legendary, contributing significantly to Hill's own stellar career.

2. Josh Allen: Allen's powerful arm and electrifying playstyle are undeniable. His combination of size, strength, and accuracy make him a formidable opponent and a clear contender for many "Top 5" lists.

3. Aaron Rodgers: A veteran with exceptional talent and a long list of accolades, Rodgers' precision and longevity in the NFL solidified his place amongst the greats. His ability to read defenses and make pinpoint throws is unmatched by many.

4. Tom Brady: The GOAT debate will likely rage on forever, but Brady's seven Super Bowl wins and countless records speak for themselves. His inclusion on any "greatest of all time" list is almost automatic.

5. Justin Herbert: Herbert's rapid ascent in the NFL is undeniable. His strong arm, impressive accuracy, and leadership qualities position him as a future Hall of Famer.

The Tua Tagovailoa Question:

The glaring absence of Tua Tagovailoa from Hill's list has sparked significant discussion. While Hill has previously expressed confidence in Tua’s abilities, the omission raises questions. Some speculate that it might be a strategic move, avoiding potential controversies or team friction. Others believe it reflects a more personal assessment of Tagovailoa's game, even if unspoken. Regardless, the lack of explanation fuels the flames of speculation.

Beyond the List: Analyzing Hill's Choices and the Fan Reaction:

Hill's list is subjective, and the criteria he used remain unclear. However, it's important to consider that this is a personal opinion, not an objective ranking based on statistical analysis. The intense reaction from fans highlights the deep emotional connection fans have with their teams and players, and the passion surrounding NFL quarterback rankings.

The Future of the Dolphins and the Hill-Tagovailoa Dynamic:

The controversy, while potentially distracting, ultimately underscores the high-stakes world of professional football. The Dolphins' success this season will depend on the continued strong performance of both Hill and Tagovailoa. How this situation impacts their on-field chemistry and team dynamics remains to be seen.

What are your thoughts on Tyreek Hill's Top 5 QB list? Share your opinion in the comments below!