Tyreek Hill Reveals Top 5 NFL Quarterbacks, Leaving Out Tua

David

3 min read

Post on May 08, 2025

4.6

Share

Tyreek Hill's Top 5 QBs: A Bold Snub of Tua Tagovailoa Sparks Debate

Kansas City Chiefs wide receiver Tyreek Hill recently dropped a bombshell, revealing his personal top five NFL quarterbacks – and notably absent from the list was his former Miami Dolphins teammate, Tua Tagovailoa. This unexpected omission has ignited a firestorm of debate among NFL fans and analysts alike, prompting discussions about Hill's criteria and the merits of various quarterbacks.

Hill, known for his blistering speed and electrifying performances, shared his ranking during an appearance on the "Million Dollaz Worth of Game" podcast. While he praised Tagovailoa's accuracy and arm talent, the omission of the Dolphins quarterback from his top five is what truly captured the attention of football fans worldwide. The revelation has sparked intense speculation and re-ignited the ongoing conversation surrounding Tua's potential and ceiling in the NFL.

Hill's Top 5 (and the Controversy it Created)

Hill's top five list, revealed with characteristic candor, included some expected names, alongside a few surprises. He didn't explicitly detail his ranking criteria, leaving room for various interpretations. However, his comments strongly suggest an emphasis on overall performance, leadership, and perhaps a certain "it" factor. The list, as reported, is as follows:

1. Patrick Mahomes: This choice is unsurprising, considering Hill's prolific success playing alongside Mahomes in Kansas City. Their on-field chemistry is legendary, and Mahomes's unparalleled talent is undeniable.
2. Josh Allen: The Buffalo Bills quarterback's powerful arm and dynamic playmaking abilities clearly resonate with Hill. Allen’s combination of size, strength, and accuracy has made him a top contender in the AFC.
3. Joe Burrow: Burrow's leadership and clutch performances, particularly in the playoffs, seem to have earned him a spot on Hill's elite list. His ability to orchestrate game-winning drives under pressure undoubtedly impressed the speedster.
4. Justin Herbert: Herbert's arm talent and impressive statistics clearly impressed Hill. The Chargers quarterback's potential is undeniable, and he represents the future of the NFL.
5. Lamar Jackson: Jackson's unique running ability and dynamic playstyle likely secured him a place on Hill's list. His electrifying style of play is unlike any other in the league.

The Tua Tagovailoa Question

The absence of Tua Tagovailoa is the most controversial aspect of Hill's ranking. While Hill acknowledged Tua's skills, stating he's "accurate as hell," the omission suggests other factors influenced his decision. Many speculate that Hill's criteria might encompass elements beyond pure statistics, perhaps including leadership qualities or intangible aspects of a quarterback's game. This has opened up a wider discussion about the complexities of evaluating NFL quarterbacks and the subjective nature of such rankings. Some believe this highlights the pressures and expectations placed on young quarterbacks in today's NFL.

The Ongoing Debate: Metrics vs. Intangibles

The reaction to Hill's list has been diverse. While some agree with his assessment, others question his exclusion of Tagovailoa, citing the latter's impressive statistics and potential. This highlights the ongoing debate in football circles about the relative importance of raw statistics versus intangible qualities like leadership and decision-making under pressure. The conversation extends beyond Tua and Hill's list, touching upon the broader challenge of evaluating quarterback talent objectively. Will Tua prove Hill wrong? Only time will tell.

Call to Action: What are your thoughts on Tyreek Hill's top 5? Share your own quarterback rankings in the comments below! Let the debate continue!