Tyreek Hill Reveals Top 5 NFL Quarterbacks: A Surprise Omission

David

3 min read

Post on May 08, 2025

4.2

Share

Tyreek Hill Reveals Top 5 NFL Quarterbacks: A Surprise Omission Sparks Debate

Kansas City Chiefs wide receiver Tyreek Hill, known for his blazing speed and electrifying plays, recently stirred the pot by revealing his personal top five NFL quarterbacks. His list, however, sparked immediate debate among fans and analysts alike, largely due to a surprising omission. The revelation, shared during an appearance on the popular podcast "I Am Athlete," has sent shockwaves through the football community, igniting discussions about quarterback rankings and the subjective nature of such lists.

Hill, who has played alongside some of the league's elite quarterbacks, including Patrick Mahomes, offered a unique perspective on the current crop of signal-callers. His top five, according to the podcast, generated significant buzz online, prompting countless articles and social media discussions. But what exactly made this list so controversial?

Hill's Top 5 NFL Quarterbacks (According to his Podcast Appearance):

While the exact order wasn't explicitly stated on the podcast, Hill reportedly included these quarterbacks in his top 5:

1. Patrick Mahomes: This selection comes as no surprise, given Hill's prolific partnership with Mahomes in Kansas City. Their connection on the field is legendary, producing countless highlight-reel plays. Mahomes' innovative playing style and unmatched arm talent undoubtedly secured his place at the top of Hill's list.

2. Josh Allen: The Buffalo Bills quarterback's powerful arm and improving accuracy clearly impressed Hill. Allen's ability to make both pinpoint throws and extend plays with his legs makes him a formidable opponent and a compelling choice for a top-five spot.

3. Jalen Hurts: The Philadelphia Eagles' star quarterback has quickly risen to the top of the NFL, showcasing his dual-threat abilities. Hurts' combination of passing prowess and rushing ability has made him a nightmare for defenses, and his inclusion in Hill's list highlights his impact on the league.

4. Joe Burrow: The Cincinnati Bengals' quarterback is known for his poise under pressure and exceptional accuracy. Burrow's clutch performances and ability to lead his team to success cemented his place in Hill's ranking.

5. Justin Herbert: Rounding out the list is the Los Angeles Chargers' Justin Herbert, whose impressive arm strength and consistent performance have made him a fan favorite. Herbert's ability to throw the ball downfield with precision is a quality that undoubtedly resonated with Hill.

The Notable Absence: A Heated Discussion

The most significant point of discussion surrounding Hill's list is the notable absence of Tom Brady. A seven-time Super Bowl champion and widely considered one of the greatest quarterbacks of all time, Brady's exclusion from a top-five list is undeniably shocking to many. This omission has fueled numerous debates online, with fans and analysts weighing in on whether Hill's assessment is accurate or simply reflects personal preference.

Some argue that Brady's longevity and unparalleled success outweigh any individual season performance. Others believe Hill's list reflects a preference for quarterbacks who excel in a more modern, dynamic style of play. Regardless, the omission is a talking point that will likely continue for some time.

Conclusion: Subjectivity in NFL Rankings

Ultimately, ranking quarterbacks is inherently subjective. Criteria such as playoff success, regular season performance, individual statistics, and playing style all contribute to the debate. Tyreek Hill's top five list serves as a fascinating snapshot of his perspective, highlighting the diverse talents and styles found amongst the league's elite quarterbacks, while also proving that even amongst the experts, there is no universally agreed-upon ranking. What do you think of Hill's list? Share your thoughts in the comments below!