The Top 10: Evaluating Success From The 2019 NFL Draft

David

3 min read

Post on Jun 13, 2025

4.7

Share

The Top 10: Evaluating Success from the 2019 NFL Draft

The 2019 NFL Draft is now a few years in the rearview mirror, providing ample time to assess the long-term impact of those selections. While some picks were instant successes, others have taken longer to develop, or sadly, haven't panned out as hoped. This retrospective analyzes the top ten picks, evaluating their contributions and ultimately grading their success. Did teams nail their first-round selections, or did some whiff spectacularly? Let's dive in.

1. Kyler Murray, QB, Arizona Cardinals: The Cardinals gambled on Murray's smaller stature, and while he's shown flashes of brilliance, inconsistency and injuries have plagued his career. His athleticism is undeniable, but his long-term viability as a franchise quarterback remains a question mark. Grade: C+

2. Nick Bosa, DE, San Francisco 49ers: Bosa has been an absolute force since entering the league. A dominant pass rusher and a cornerstone of the 49ers' defense, he's lived up to, and perhaps exceeded, expectations. A Defensive Player of the Year candidate almost immediately, Bosa is a clear success story. Grade: A+

3. Quinnen Williams, DT, New York Jets: Williams has shown potential as a disruptive interior lineman, but consistency and injuries have hampered his impact. He hasn't quite reached the elite level many projected, but remains a valuable player for the Jets. Grade: B-

4. Josh Allen, T, Jacksonville Jaguars: Allen’s selection was seen as a need for the Jaguars, and he's generally performed well as a reliable left tackle. While not a flashy name, his consistent performance solidifies his pick as a smart one. Grade: B+

5. Devin White, LB, Tampa Bay Buccaneers: White has become a key player in Tampa Bay's defense, showcasing his athleticism and playmaking ability. A consistent contributor, his impact on the Buccaneers' Super Bowl run further cements his successful draft status. Grade: A

6. Jonah Williams, OT, Cincinnati Bengals: After overcoming early injuries, Williams has established himself as a solid left tackle for the Bengals. A testament to his resilience, he's proven to be a valuable asset on the offensive line. Grade: B

7. Ed Oliver, DT, Buffalo Bills: Oliver’s production has been a bit of a mixed bag, showing bursts of dominance but lacking the consistency expected of a top-ten pick. He's certainly a force, but perhaps not quite the game-changer projected. Grade: B-

8. Rashan Gary, DE, Green Bay Packers: Gary's development has been a slow burn, but he's steadily improved and become a valuable contributor to the Packers' strong defensive line. Patience with Gary has paid off for Green Bay. Grade: B+

9. T.J. Hockenson, TE, Detroit Lions: Hockenson has been a reliable receiving threat and a valuable part of the Lions' offense, demonstrating consistent production despite the team's struggles. Grade: A-

10. Clelin Ferrell, DE, Oakland Raiders (now Las Vegas Raiders): Ferrell's NFL career hasn't lived up to expectations, failing to consistently make a significant impact. He's a prime example of a high draft pick that didn't translate into on-field success. Grade: D

Analyzing the 2019 Draft's Impact:

The 2019 NFL Draft highlights the unpredictability of the NFL. While some teams found immediate stars, others are still waiting for their high picks to reach their full potential. This analysis demonstrates the importance of player development, team fit, and a bit of luck in achieving success in the NFL draft. The long-term impact of these players will continue to unfold in the coming seasons.

What are your thoughts on the 2019 NFL Draft? Share your opinions in the comments below!