Start 'Em, Sit 'Em: NFL Week 2 Fantasy Football Advice – McLaurin Vs. McMillan

David

3 min read

Post on Sep 12, 2025

4.5

Share

Start 'Em, Sit 'Em: NFL Week 2 Fantasy Football Advice – McLaurin vs. McMillan

Fantasy football managers everywhere are agonizing over their Week 2 lineups. This week presents some tough choices, and the Terry McLaurin versus Khalil Herbert debate is a prime example. Should you trust the Commanders' veteran receiver after a shaky Week 1, or roll the dice on the surging Chicago Bears running back? We're here to help you navigate these crucial decisions with our expert Start 'Em, Sit 'Em advice.

Terry McLaurin: A Risky Start or a Safe Sit?

Terry McLaurin, a consistent fantasy producer in past seasons, had a relatively quiet Week 1 against the Arizona Cardinals. While he didn't completely disappoint, his performance wasn't the explosive output fantasy owners crave. This week's matchup against the Denver Broncos defense presents both challenges and opportunities. The Broncos' secondary is capable, but their pass rush can be inconsistent. This means McLaurin could see some single coverage opportunities, but he'll also need to fight for every yard.

Factors to Consider:

• Sam Howell's Performance: Howell's consistency is a major question mark. McLaurin's fantasy value is directly tied to Howell's ability to deliver the ball accurately and effectively.
• Commanders' Offensive Scheme: The Washington Commanders’ offense is still finding its rhythm. Their reliance on the run game could limit McLaurin's targets.
• Broncos' Secondary: Denver's secondary has shown flashes of brilliance but also significant vulnerability. McLaurin's talent gives him a chance to break out, but it's not a guaranteed win.

Verdict: McLaurin is a risky start in Week 2. While his upside is undeniable, the potential for a low-scoring game and limited targets makes him a borderline WR2/flex play at best. Consider him a Sit unless you're desperate for a high-upside gamble.

Khalil Herbert: A Week 2 Breakout Candidate?

Khalil Herbert surprised many with his strong performance in Week 1, showcasing his explosive running style and securing a significant role in the Chicago Bears’ offense. With the departure of David Montgomery, Herbert steps into a featured role, making him a far more appealing fantasy option. Facing the Tampa Bay Buccaneers defense this week, however, presents a tougher test.

Factors to Consider:

• Featured Back Role: Herbert is clearly the lead back in Chicago, giving him a high floor in terms of carries and opportunities.
• Tampa Bay's Run Defense: The Buccaneers' run defense, while capable, isn't impenetrable. Herbert's ability to break big plays could make him a valuable fantasy asset despite the tough matchup.
• Game Script: If the Bears fall behind early, Herbert's touches could decrease as they are forced to throw more.

Verdict: Despite the challenging matchup against Tampa Bay, Khalil Herbert is a solid Start for Week 2. His secured role within the Bears' offense and potential for explosive plays outweigh the risk. He's a reliable RB2 with upside.

Conclusion: McLaurin vs. McMillan – The Verdict

While both players present interesting fantasy dilemmas, our analysis suggests different approaches. Sit McLaurin unless you're comfortable with significant risk, while Start Herbert with confidence as a solid RB2. Remember to always consider your own team's needs and bench strength before making your final lineup decisions. Good luck in Week 2!

Further Reading:

Disclaimer: This article provides fantasy football advice based on available information and analysis. Fantasy football outcomes are inherently unpredictable, and this advice should not be considered a guarantee of success.