Should Cody Rhodes Return To WWE SmackDown? Analyzing The Current Situation

David

3 min read

Post on May 24, 2025

4.5

Share

Should Cody Rhodes Return to WWE SmackDown? Analyzing the Current Situation

The wrestling world is buzzing with speculation: should Cody Rhodes return to WWE SmackDown? His unexpected loss at WrestleMania 39 to Roman Reigns left fans reeling, and the question of his next move hangs heavy in the air. While his future remains unwritten, a return to the blue brand presents a compelling, albeit complex, scenario. This article dives deep into the current situation, analyzing the pros and cons of a potential SmackDown homecoming for "The American Nightmare."

The Allure of SmackDown:

Several factors point towards a potential SmackDown return for Cody Rhodes. Firstly, the brand currently lacks a true top-tier babyface. While stars like Rey Mysterio and Drew McIntyre hold significant fan appeal, neither commands the same level of mainstream recognition and drawing power as Rhodes. His presence could instantly elevate the brand's profile and inject a much-needed shot of adrenaline into the main event scene.

Secondly, a SmackDown return offers a compelling narrative arc. After his heartbreaking loss at WrestleMania, a renewed focus on building towards another championship opportunity would resonate deeply with fans. The opportunity to feud with established SmackDown stars like Gunther, or even a surprise return of a past rival, could provide captivating storylines. Imagine a clash between Rhodes and The Bloodline – the possibilities are endless.

Arguments Against a SmackDown Move:

While a SmackDown move seems appealing on the surface, several factors warrant consideration. The most significant is the potential for stagnation. If Rhodes simply repeats the same formula used on Raw, his return might feel less impactful. WWE needs to avoid repeating past storylines and offer a fresh, innovative approach to capitalize on his popularity.

Furthermore, the current SmackDown landscape is already crowded with established stars. Integrating Rhodes seamlessly into the existing storylines without overshadowing other talents would require careful planning and execution. A poorly handled return could inadvertently diminish other wrestlers' opportunities and impact the overall dynamic of the brand.

Exploring Alternative Scenarios:

Beyond SmackDown, other possibilities exist for Cody Rhodes. A sustained absence from television could build anticipation for an even more spectacular return later down the line. This could involve a compelling storyline that justifies his absence and creates a sense of mystery, leading to a bigger pop upon his eventual comeback. Alternatively, a move to NXT could see him mentoring the next generation of WWE superstars, furthering his legacy and building a new fanbase.

The Verdict:

A Cody Rhodes return to WWE SmackDown is certainly plausible, and offers significant benefits. However, WWE must meticulously plan his return to avoid diluting his impact. The key is to craft a compelling narrative that distinguishes his SmackDown run from his Raw tenure, ensuring his presence genuinely elevates the brand and provides compelling storylines for both him and other wrestlers. Only time will tell if "The American Nightmare" will indeed grace the blue brand, but one thing is certain: the wrestling world will be watching with bated breath.

What are your thoughts? Should Cody Rhodes return to SmackDown? Let us know in the comments below!