Ranking The Underdogs: NFL's Most Likely Playoff Dark Horses For 2023

David

3 min read

Post on May 08, 2025

4.8

Share

Ranking the Underdogs: NFL's Most Likely Playoff Dark Horses for 2023

The NFL season is upon us, and while the usual suspects like the Kansas City Chiefs and Buffalo Bills are expected to contend, the playoffs are often a breeding ground for surprises. This year promises to be no different. Several teams, flying under the radar, possess the potential to emerge as genuine playoff dark horses. Let's rank the most likely candidates to make a surprising postseason run in 2023.

Methodology: Our rankings consider a combination of factors including offseason improvements, key player health, strength of schedule, coaching stability, and overall team chemistry. We're looking beyond the pre-season hype to identify teams with the potential to exceed expectations.

1. Detroit Lions: The Lions roared back into relevance in 2022, narrowly missing the playoffs despite a significant improvement. With a potent offense led by Jared Goff and a blossoming young star in running back Jahmyr Gibbs, Detroit's success hinges on their defensive performance. If their defense can take a substantial step forward, the Lions could easily snatch a Wild Card spot. Their improved offensive line also adds a crucial layer of protection for Goff. Keywords: Detroit Lions, Jared Goff, Jahmyr Gibbs, NFL Playoffs, NFL Dark Horse

2. New York Jets: The arrival of Aaron Rodgers in New York immediately catapulted the Jets into the playoff conversation. However, their success depends heavily on Rodgers' ability to adapt to a new system and the overall health of the team. If the offensive line protects Rodgers effectively and the running game provides balance, the Jets possess the firepower to compete with the AFC's elite. A strong defense is already in place, providing a solid foundation for a potential playoff push. Keywords: New York Jets, Aaron Rodgers, AFC Playoffs, NFL Predictions, NFL Dark Horse

3. Jacksonville Jaguars: After a surprising run to the AFC Divisional Round in 2022, the Jaguars are poised for another strong season. With Trevor Lawrence entering his third year, the offensive potential is undeniable. Their defensive improvements will be crucial, particularly in stopping the run. If they can maintain consistency throughout the season, the Jaguars are a formidable playoff contender in a competitive AFC South. Keywords: Jacksonville Jaguars, Trevor Lawrence, AFC South, NFL Playoffs, NFL Dark Horse

4. Seattle Seahawks: The Seahawks exceeded expectations last year, showcasing a dynamic offense led by Geno Smith. While their defense still needs work, their offensive firepower and the explosive potential of Kenneth Walker III at running back make them a threat. Maintaining their offensive momentum and securing crucial wins against divisional opponents will determine if Seattle makes a return to the playoffs. Keywords: Seattle Seahawks, Geno Smith, Kenneth Walker III, NFC West, NFL Playoffs

5. Dallas Cowboys: While not a complete underdog, the Cowboys' playoff chances remain unpredictable due to their inconsistent performance in recent years. The strength of their offense, spearheaded by Dak Prescott, and their usually dominant defense, make them a dangerous team. However, overcoming injuries and maintaining consistency throughout the season are key to a successful playoff run. Keywords: Dallas Cowboys, Dak Prescott, NFC East, NFL Playoffs, NFL Predictions

Honorable Mentions: The Washington Commanders and the New Orleans Saints also possess outside chances of making the playoffs. Both teams have undergone significant changes and could surprise many with a strong performance.

Conclusion: While predicting the NFL playoffs is notoriously difficult, these five teams present the most compelling cases for dark horse contenders. Their success hinges on overcoming specific challenges and maintaining consistent performance throughout the season. Keep an eye on these teams—they could be the surprise stories of the 2023 NFL season. What team do you think will make the biggest surprise playoff run? Let us know in the comments below!