Ranking The Underdogs: NFL's Most Likely Fringe Playoff Contenders In 2023

4 min read Post on Jun 12, 2025

Ranking the Underdogs: NFL's Most Likely Fringe Playoff Contenders in 2023

The NFL is a league of parity, where any team on any given Sunday can pull off an upset. But as the 2023 season approaches, some teams find themselves on the fringes of playoff contention, poised to either break through or fall short. Forget the usual Super Bowl favorites; this article dives deep into analyzing the underdogs with the best chance of making the postseason this year. We'll rank them based on roster strength, coaching acumen, schedule difficulty, and overall potential for a surprise run.

5. The New York Jets: A Quarterback Question Mark, But Loaded With Talent

The Jets are a fascinating case study. With Aaron Rodgers now under center, the team boasts a significantly upgraded quarterback position compared to last year. However, Rodgers' age and injury history are legitimate concerns. The Jets’ strength lies in their exceptional defense and a formidable running game. Their success hinges on Rodgers staying healthy and adapting to new offensive coordinator Nathaniel Hackett's system. A relatively easy early-season schedule could be key to building momentum. Their playoff hopes ride on Rodgers' performance and the team's ability to avoid debilitating injuries.

Strengths: Elite defense, strong running game, improved quarterback situation.
Weaknesses: Question marks surrounding Rodgers' health and performance, potential offensive line inconsistencies.

4. The Detroit Lions: A High-Octane Offense Looking for Consistency

The Lions were a breath of fresh air last season, showcasing a thrilling, high-powered offense led by Jared Goff. They fell short in the final stretch, but significant improvements in their defense during the off-season make them a serious playoff contender. Their young, exciting team is hungry for success, and a favorable schedule could help them secure a wild-card spot. The key for Detroit is consistency – avoiding those frustrating collapses that plagued them in 2022.

Strengths: Explosive offense, improved defense, strong coaching staff.
Weaknesses: Defense still needs to prove its consistency, relying heavily on Goff's performance.

3. The Green Bay Packers: A New Era Begins in Green Bay

The post-Aaron Rodgers era has begun in Green Bay, and the Packers are facing a significant rebuild. However, Jordan Love's potential, coupled with a strong running game and a solid defense, makes them a dark horse. Their success depends on Love's development and the offensive line's ability to protect him. A less forgiving schedule compared to other teams on this list makes their playoff push an even greater uphill battle.

Strengths: Strong running game, solid defense, potential for Love to exceed expectations.
Weaknesses: Uncertainty surrounding Love's performance, tough schedule.

2. The Cleveland Browns: Talent is Abundant, but Can They Stay Healthy?

The Browns possess immense offensive talent, with a dynamic running game and a capable quarterback in Deshaun Watson. However, injuries have plagued them in recent years, and their playoff chances depend on their ability to stay healthy. Their defense needs to consistently perform at a high level, preventing big plays that could derail their chances. If the Browns can stay injury-free, their potent offense and improved defense could propel them to a playoff berth.

Strengths: Exceptional offensive talent, strong running game, improved defensive potential.
Weaknesses: Injury history, consistency issues on defense, reliance on Watson’s performance post-suspension.

1. The Pittsburgh Steelers: A Solid Foundation, Poised for a Breakout Season

The Steelers consistently find ways to compete, and with Kenny Pickett entering his second season, they could be ready for a playoff run. Their strong running game, coupled with a solid defense, creates a balanced team capable of winning close games. While their playoff chances hinge on Pickett's improvement, the Steelers' overall roster strength and coaching stability give them the highest probability of making the playoffs among the underdogs.

Strengths: Strong running game, solid defense, experienced coaching staff.
Weaknesses: Need Pickett to make significant strides, facing a tough AFC North division.

Conclusion: The NFL's playoff race is always unpredictable, but these five teams possess the talent and potential to make a serious run. Their success will depend on several key factors, including injury prevention, quarterback performance, and the ability to overcome tough opponents. Keep an eye on these underdogs as the 2023 season unfolds. Which team do you think will surprise us all and make the playoffs? Let us know in the comments!