Ranking The Top Backup Quarterbacks: Who Could Spearhead A 2024 NFL Playoff Contender?

David

3 min read

Post on May 08, 2025

4.4

Share

Ranking the Top Backup Quarterbacks: Who Could Spearhead a 2024 NFL Playoff Contender?

The NFL is a league of attrition, especially at the quarterback position. One devastating injury can shatter even the most promising playoff hopes. That's why having a capable backup quarterback isn't just a luxury—it's a necessity for any team aiming for Super Bowl contention in 2024. But which backups possess the talent to step in and lead a team to postseason success? Let's rank the top contenders.

Methodology: This ranking considers a combination of factors including past performance, proven NFL experience, arm talent, mobility, and overall potential to succeed in a starting role. We've excluded quarterbacks projected to start in 2023, focusing solely on players likely to be backups entering the new season.

Tier 1: The Elite Understudies

1. Brock Purdy (San Francisco 49ers): Purdy's late-season surge in 2022, before his elbow injury, catapults him to the top of this list. His accuracy, decision-making, and leadership are exceptional. While recovering from injury, his potential to lead a playoff run remains incredibly high, making him the gold standard for backup QBs. [Link to an article about Purdy's recovery]

2. Cooper Rush (Dallas Cowboys): A consistent performer who's proven he can win games in the NFL. Rush's experience and game management skills make him a valuable asset for any team. His calm demeanor under pressure is a key asset. [Link to a Cowboys' team page]

Tier 2: Solid Contributors with High Up-Side

3. Gardner Minshew (Indianapolis Colts): Minshew possesses a strong arm and the ability to make plays outside the pocket. While his consistency has been questioned, his upside is undeniable. A team needing a spark could do far worse. [Link to a Minshew highlight reel - external link]

4. Jacoby Brissett (Washington Commanders): A veteran with extensive starting experience, Brissett offers stability and reliability. While not a flashy player, he provides a steady hand in the event of an injury. His experience managing games is invaluable.

Tier 3: Potential Dark Horses

5. Teddy Bridgewater (New Orleans Saints - Status Uncertain): Bridgewater's injury history is a concern, but when healthy, he's a capable game manager. His experience and accuracy could make him a valuable backup for a contender.

6. Nathan Peterman (Las Vegas Raiders - Status Uncertain): Peterman's career has been up and down, but he remains in the league for a reason. His experience could be beneficial in a pinch, though he would need a significant improvement to genuinely spearhead a playoff run.

Factors Affecting Backup QB Value:

• Offensive Scheme: A backup QB's success is heavily reliant on the offensive system. A simpler, more run-oriented offense can better mask a backup's limitations.
• Supporting Cast: A strong offensive line, reliable running backs, and capable receivers can elevate even a mediocre backup.
• Coaching: A good coaching staff can help a backup QB prepare and adjust to a starting role quickly and effectively.

Conclusion:

While no backup quarterback guarantees a playoff run, the players listed above represent the best chances for teams to maintain competitiveness should their starter go down. Their value extends beyond just filling a roster spot; they are insurance policies against catastrophic injury, offering a chance to keep a team's playoff hopes alive. The 2024 season will reveal which of these quarterbacks can rise to the occasion and become unlikely heroes. Stay tuned!