Ranking The Top Backup Quarterbacks: Who Could Carry An NFL Team To The Playoffs In 2024?

David

3 min read

Post on May 30, 2025

4.7

Share

Ranking the Top Backup Quarterbacks: Who Could Carry an NFL Team to the Playoffs in 2024?

The NFL is a league of unforgiving attrition, where injuries can derail even the most promising seasons. For many teams, the difference between a playoff berth and a disappointing year rests squarely on the shoulders of their backup quarterback. So, who among this year's understudies possesses the talent to not just fill in, but potentially lead their team to the postseason in 2024? Let's dive into our ranking of the top backup quarterbacks.

The Criteria: Our ranking considers several factors, including past performance, experience, arm talent, mobility, and overall leadership qualities. While a dazzling preseason performance doesn't guarantee success, it offers a glimpse into potential. We've also considered the supporting cast each backup would inherit if thrust into a starting role.

Tier 1: Playoff-Caliber Potential

1. Brock Purdy (San Francisco 49ers): Purdy's remarkable late-season surge in 2022, before his unfortunate injury, catapults him to the top of this list. He showed poise, accuracy, and a surprising ability to manage the 49ers' complex offense. His recovery from injury is key, but his potential is undeniable. If healthy, Purdy could easily lead a playoff run.

2. Cooper Rush (Dallas Cowboys): A consistent performer in limited action, Rush has proven he can win games at the NFL level. While not possessing the same ceiling as Purdy, his experience in Dallas' system and his ability to manage the game effectively give him a strong chance to succeed if called upon.

3. Gardner Minshew (Indianapolis Colts): Minshew has a proven track record as a starter, showing flashes of brilliance and a fearless playing style. His experience managing games and his arm talent make him a valuable asset for any team. The Colts' roster strength will be a significant factor in his potential playoff success.

Tier 2: Promising but Unproven

1. Malik Willis (Tennessee Titans): Willis possesses exceptional athleticism and arm strength, though his accuracy and decision-making need refinement. With a strong supporting cast and more time to develop, he could emerge as a potential playoff contender. His upside is significant, making him a wild card in this ranking.

2. Desmond Ridder (Atlanta Falcons): Ridder's performance at the end of last season was encouraging, showcasing improvement and a growing command of the offense. While still developing, his potential to lead a playoff run is steadily increasing, especially given the Falcons' young, talented roster.

Tier 3: Solid Depth, but Unlikely Playoff Contenders

This tier includes quarterbacks like Jacoby Brissett (Washington Commanders), who provide reliable backup options, but their likelihood of leading a team to the playoffs is significantly lower. Their experience and stability are invaluable, but their skill sets may not be enough to propel a team to a championship run.

Factors Beyond the Quarterback:

It's crucial to remember that a backup quarterback's success isn't solely dependent on their individual talent. A strong offensive line, a reliable running game, and a potent defense are all essential for a successful playoff run. Even the best backup quarterback will struggle without sufficient support.

Conclusion:

The 2024 NFL season's success for many teams may hinge on the performance of their backup quarterbacks. While Brock Purdy currently sits at the top of our list due to his proven ability, other quarterbacks like Cooper Rush and Gardner Minshew possess the potential to lead their respective teams to the playoffs. The upcoming season will undoubtedly test the mettle of these players, revealing who truly has the "it" factor to shine under pressure. Stay tuned!

Call to Action: Who do you think will be the most impactful backup quarterback in 2024? Share your predictions in the comments below!