Ranking The Most Likely NFL Playoff Underdogs For 2023

David

3 min read

Post on May 12, 2025

4.8

Share

Ranking the Most Likely NFL Playoff Underdogs for 2023

The NFL season is upon us, and with it comes the exhilarating, nail-biting anticipation of the playoffs. While some teams are clear favorites, the beauty of the NFL lies in its unpredictability. This year, several teams are poised to become unlikely playoff contenders – the ultimate underdogs. But which ones have the best chance of pulling off a Cinderella story? We've ranked the most likely NFL playoff underdogs for 2023, factoring in team performance, roster changes, and overall division strength.

Methodology: Our ranking considers several factors beyond simple win predictions. We've analyzed each team's projected strength of schedule, key player health, coaching changes, and overall team chemistry. This isn't just about predicting wins; it's about identifying teams with the potential to exceed expectations and make a deep playoff run.

5. The New York Jets: The Jets are a fascinating case study. With Aaron Rodgers under center, their offense has the potential to explode. However, their success hinges on their offensive line's ability to protect Rodgers and the consistency of their running game. A strong start is crucial for the Jets to build momentum and solidify their playoff hopes. Their defense, already a strong unit, needs to stay healthy and consistently perform at a high level to support their offensive aspirations. This puts them squarely in underdog territory, capable of a strong playoff push if things break their way.

4. The Detroit Lions: The Lions surprised many last season with their improved offense and exciting brand of football. Their young quarterback, Jared Goff, showed significant improvement, and their dynamic receiving corps promises explosive plays. The key for Detroit is tightening up their defense. If they can significantly improve their defensive performance, they'll be a serious threat in the NFC. They're primed to compete for a Wild Card spot, making them a credible underdog team.

3. The Green Bay Packers: The departure of Aaron Rodgers leaves a massive void, but Jordan Love has a chance to prove himself. The Packers have a strong running game and a solid defense. Their success will depend heavily on Love's development and the team's ability to adapt to a new offensive identity. A surprisingly strong season from Love could propel the Packers back into playoff contention, establishing them as genuine underdogs.

2. The Atlanta Falcons: With a young, dynamic quarterback in Desmond Ridder and a revamped coaching staff, the Falcons are aiming for a significant leap forward. Their success hinges on Ridder's development and the offensive line's ability to protect him. A strong running game, complemented by a vastly improved defense, could see them compete for a Wild Card spot, making them a dark horse contender.

1. The Pittsburgh Steelers: The Steelers boast a solid defense and a promising young quarterback in Kenny Pickett. Their success will hinge on Pickett's continued improvement and the overall performance of their offensive line. If Pickett takes another leap forward and the offensive line can provide consistent protection, the Steelers could be a surprise playoff team. Their strong running game and improving defense give them a solid foundation for a playoff push.

Conclusion: While these teams are considered underdogs, they all possess the talent and potential to make a significant impact in the 2023 NFL season. The playoffs are a crucible of pressure and talent; these teams will need to perform consistently to achieve their ultimate goal. Which of these underdogs will rise to the occasion? Only time will tell. Stay tuned for an exciting season of NFL football!

Call to Action: Who do you think is the most likely NFL playoff underdog this year? Share your predictions in the comments below!