Ranking The Best Backup Quarterbacks: Their Chances Of A 2024 NFL Playoff Victory

David

3 min read

Post on Jun 20, 2025

4.9

Share

Ranking the Best Backup Quarterbacks: Their Chances of a 2024 NFL Playoff Victory

The 2023 NFL season showcased the critical role of backup quarterbacks. Injuries are inevitable, and a team's playoff hopes can hinge on the performance of their second-string signal-caller. So, as we look ahead to the 2024 season, let's analyze the backup quarterbacks most likely to lead their teams to postseason success. This ranking considers factors like experience, recent performance, and the overall strength of their respective teams.

Methodology: This ranking isn't just about raw talent; it integrates the backup QB's capabilities with the supporting cast. A brilliant backup on a weak team has less chance of playoff glory than a competent one on a Super Bowl contender.

Top Tier: The Playoff Contenders

1. Brock Purdy (San Francisco 49ers): Purdy's late-season emergence in 2022, despite a significant injury, catapults him to the top. He showed poise and accuracy beyond his years. While the 49ers boast a potent offense and defense, Purdy's ability to manage the game and make key throws is invaluable should injury strike Trey Lance or Sam Darnold. His chances of leading the 49ers deep into the playoffs are exceptionally high.

2. Cooper Rush (Dallas Cowboys): Rush has proven his ability to win games in Dallas, stepping in admirably for Dak Prescott in the past. The Cowboys' strong offensive line and potent running game provide a solid foundation for Rush's game management style. His experience within the system gives him an edge, making him a reliable option should Prescott face injury.

3. Gardner Minshew II (Indianapolis Colts): Minshew has shown flashes of brilliance throughout his career. While his landing spot in Indianapolis remains to be seen in terms of its playoff potential, his experience and arm talent could elevate him to a playoff hero if given the opportunity.

Mid-Tier: The Dark Horses

4. Will Grier (Dallas Cowboys): Grier's experience as a former third-round draft pick and time in the system makes him a solid option if injury strikes. However, his limited game experience puts him lower on this list than Rush.

5. Bailey Zappe (New England Patriots): Zappe's solid performance in limited action during the 2022 season earns him a spot. But the Patriots' overall offensive consistency needs improvement, impacting Zappe's potential.

Lower Tier: The Long Shots

This category includes quarterbacks with limited NFL experience or those on teams with less overall playoff potential. While these backups are valuable for depth, their chances of leading a playoff run are significantly lower. Examples include many of the league's younger backups, whose promise lies in future potential rather than immediate playoff impact.

Factors Affecting Backup QB Playoff Success

• Team Strength: A strong supporting cast is crucial. Even the best backup quarterback struggles without a robust offensive line, a reliable running game, and a solid defense.
• Offensive System Familiarity: Knowing the playbook inside and out gives a backup quarterback a significant advantage.
• Experience: Game experience under pressure is invaluable.
• Coaching Staff: A capable coaching staff can make all the difference in preparing a backup quarterback for success.

Conclusion: The 2024 NFL season will be a test for several backup quarterbacks. While Brock Purdy stands out as the most likely candidate to lead his team to a playoff victory, other names like Cooper Rush and potentially Gardner Minshew II present intriguing possibilities depending on the health and overall performance of the starting quarterbacks. The unexpected always happens in the NFL, making backup quarterback performance a crucial element in playoff contention. Keep an eye on these players – their performances could determine the course of the season.

Call to Action: What are your predictions for the backup quarterbacks in the 2024 NFL season? Share your thoughts in the comments below!