Ranking The Best Backup QBs: Who Could Carry An NFL Team To The Playoffs In 2024?

David

3 min read

Post on May 20, 2025

4.3

Share

Ranking the Best Backup QBs: Who Could Carry an NFL Team to the Playoffs in 2024?

The NFL is a league of attrition, especially at the quarterback position. One devastating injury can derail even the most promising season. So, while star quarterbacks grab the headlines, the quality of backup quarterbacks often determines a team's playoff fate. As we look ahead to the 2024 season, let's rank some of the league's best backup QBs and assess their potential to lead a team to postseason glory.

The Top Tier: Playoff-Ready Potential

This group possesses the experience and talent to not only manage games but potentially win them consistently, even carrying a team through a playoff run.

1. Brock Purdy (San Francisco 49ers): Purdy's surprising late-season success in 2022, culminating in a dominant playoff performance before injury, catapults him to the top. His arm talent, quick decision-making, and overall composure make him a legitimate starting-caliber quarterback. If he's healthy, the 49ers are in excellent hands, even without Trey Lance or Sam Darnold.

2. Jordan Love (Green Bay Packers): After years of learning behind Aaron Rodgers, Love finally gets his shot. His preseason performances showcased improved accuracy and decision-making. While he needs to prove himself over a full season, his potential is undeniable, and the Packers' supporting cast could give him a fighting chance.

3. Gardner Minshew (Indianapolis Colts): A fan favorite known for his charisma and surprisingly strong play, Minshew has proven himself capable of leading an NFL offense. His experience and improvisational skills make him a valuable asset for any team. Although Anthony Richardson is expected to start for the Colts, Minshew provides vital insurance.

The Solid Second Tier: Capable of Winning Games

These quarterbacks are unlikely to lead a prolonged playoff run, but they can win enough games to keep a team competitive in the right circumstances.

4. Cooper Rush (Dallas Cowboys): Rush’s steadiness and experience within the Cowboys’ system are invaluable. While he won't dazzle with highlight-reel plays, his consistency and ability to avoid critical turnovers make him a reliable option.

5. Teddy Bridgewater (Detroit Lions): A veteran with plenty of starting experience, Bridgewater brings stability and leadership. While his upside might be limited, he can manage a game effectively and keep a team in contention.

The Developing Talent: Potential for Future Success

These backups are younger and less proven, but possess the potential to rise to the occasion given the right opportunity and development.

6. Malik Willis (Tennessee Titans): Willis needs more time to develop, but his athleticism and raw talent are intriguing. A strong supporting cast and coaching staff could unlock his potential.

7. Bailey Zappe (New England Patriots): Zappe showed flashes of promise in limited action. More experience is crucial, but he possesses the arm strength and accuracy to become a reliable backup.

Factors Beyond the Player:

While quarterback talent is critical, several other factors influence a backup's success:

• Offensive Line: A strong offensive line can mask quarterback deficiencies, giving the backup more time to make plays.
• Coaching Staff: A well-designed game plan tailored to the backup's strengths can significantly improve their chances of success.
• Supporting Cast: A strong running game and reliable receiving corps can take pressure off the backup quarterback.

Conclusion:

The 2024 season will likely see several backup quarterbacks thrust into starting roles. The quarterbacks listed above represent a range of experience and potential, highlighting the importance of having a reliable backup in the ever-unpredictable NFL. Keep an eye on these players – they might just be the heroes of an unexpected playoff run. Who do you think will surprise us the most? Let us know in the comments!