Ranking The Best Backup QBs: Who Could Carry An NFL Team In 2024?

David

3 min read

Post on Jun 22, 2025

4.1

Share

Ranking the Best Backup QBs: Who Could Carry an NFL Team in 2024?

The NFL season is a brutal marathon, and injuries are an inevitable part of the game. For teams hoping to contend for a Super Bowl, having a capable backup quarterback is no longer a luxury—it's a necessity. So, who among the league's understudies possesses the talent to step up and lead their team to victory should their starter go down? Let's rank the top backup quarterbacks heading into the 2024 season, considering their experience, skillset, and potential to perform under pressure.

Methodology: This ranking considers a combination of factors, including past performance, proficiency in various offensive systems, arm talent, decision-making under pressure, and overall leadership qualities. While raw statistics are important, we've also emphasized potential and the intangible qualities that define a successful NFL quarterback.

Tier 1: The Franchise Fill-Ins

These quarterbacks have proven they can win games at the NFL level and could seamlessly step into a starting role.

1. Brock Purdy (San Francisco 49ers): Purdy's surprising late-season performance in 2022 catapulted him to the top of this list. Despite his injury, his composure, accuracy, and ability to manage the 49ers' complex offense are undeniable. His quick processing and understanding of the game make him a true franchise-caliber backup.

2. Jordan Love (Green Bay Packers): After years of sitting behind Aaron Rodgers, Love finally got his chance in 2023. His performance will be crucial in determining his final ranking, but his arm talent and mobility are evident. The Packers clearly believe in his potential, and a strong 2023 campaign could solidify his place among the elite backups.

Tier 2: Promising Prospects with Potential

These quarterbacks have shown flashes of brilliance and possess the potential to become reliable starters, but might need a bit more seasoning.

3. Desmond Ridder (Atlanta Falcons): Ridder showed improvement towards the end of the 2022 season. His mobility and arm strength are assets, and a strong showing in 2023 could easily propel him higher in future rankings. Further development in reading defenses will be key.

4. Bailey Zappe (New England Patriots): Zappe impressed in limited action during the 2022 season. His accuracy and game management skills are notable strengths, and continued development within the Patriots' system could establish him as a dependable backup.

Tier 3: Solid Veterans and Developing Talents

This tier includes quarterbacks who offer experience and reliability, but might not possess the upside of the top tiers.

5. Cooper Rush (Dallas Cowboys): Rush has proven he can win games in relief of Dak Prescott. While his ceiling might be lower than some others on this list, his consistency and experience make him a valuable asset.

Factors Affecting Backup QB Value:

• Offensive System Familiarity: A quarterback who already understands the system will transition more seamlessly into a starting role.
• Coaching Staff: A supportive coaching staff can help a backup quarterback develop and thrive in the face of unexpected opportunities.
• Team Roster: A strong supporting cast can make a backup quarterback's job significantly easier.

The Bottom Line:

The importance of a reliable backup quarterback cannot be overstated. The quarterbacks listed above represent a range of talent and potential, and their performances in the upcoming season will be crucial in shaping their legacies and the fortunes of their respective teams. Keep an eye on these players – they could be the difference between a playoff run and an early exit in 2024. What do you think? Who is the most underrated backup QB in the league? Let us know in the comments below!