Ranking The Best Backup QBs: Predicting A 2024 NFL Playoff Surprise

3 min read Post on Jun 05, 2025

Ranking the Best Backup QBs: Predicting a 2024 NFL Playoff Surprise

The NFL season is a whirlwind of unpredictable twists and turns. While star quarterbacks grab headlines, the unsung heroes – the backup quarterbacks – often lurk in the shadows, ready to seize their moment. With the 2024 season on the horizon, we're diving deep into the ranks of the league's best backup quarterbacks, analyzing their potential and predicting which team might experience a surprising playoff run fueled by their understudy. Could a backup QB lead their team to unexpected glory? Let's explore.

The Top Tier: Ready to Shine

Several backup quarterbacks possess the talent and experience to seamlessly step into a starting role and deliver winning performances. These aren't just clipboard holders; they're legitimate NFL-caliber players waiting for their chance.

Brock Purdy (San Francisco 49ers): Purdy's impressive late-season surge in 2022 proved his capabilities. While recovering from injury, his potential remains undeniable. The 49ers' success hinges heavily on his health, but a healthy Purdy could elevate San Francisco even further.
Cooper Rush (Dallas Cowboys): Rush has consistently proven his reliability, stepping in for Dak Prescott and delivering wins. His game management skills and experience within the Cowboys’ system make him a valuable asset. Don't count out the Cowboys even if Prescott faces injury.
Gardner Minshew (Indianapolis Colts): Minshew's electric playing style and ability to extend plays make him a wildcard. While perhaps not as polished as others on this list, his potential to spark an offense is high, making him a player to watch in Indy.

The Contenders: Potential Playoff Impact

This next tier features quarterbacks with a blend of experience and upside, capable of making a meaningful contribution should their team require their services. Their potential to lead a surprise playoff run is very real.

Will Grier (Dallas Cowboys): While his NFL experience is limited, Grier's potential remains untapped. He boasts a strong arm and could make a significant impact if called upon.
Jacob Eason (Seattle Seahawks): Eason's arm strength and athleticism make him a sleeper pick. While he has yet to establish himself in the league, the Seahawks have shown a willingness to take chances on young quarterbacks.

The Dark Horses: Unlikely Heroes?

These backups may be less heralded, but they have the potential to surprise everyone if given the opportunity. An injury to a starting QB could catapult one of these players into the spotlight.

Nathan Peterman (Chicago Bears): A name that evokes mixed reactions, Peterman's journey has been unusual. His potential might be limited, but a miracle performance is not impossible.
Several Undrafted Free Agents: Every year, several talented undrafted free agents compete for backup positions. While less likely, one could emerge as a diamond in the rough and make a surprising impact.

Predicting the 2024 Playoff Surprise

While predicting the future is impossible, we believe the Dallas Cowboys are poised for a potential playoff surprise fueled by their backup quarterbacks. The combination of Cooper Rush's experience and Will Grier's potential provides a safety net if Dak Prescott faces injury. Their strong defense and overall team talent would allow a capable backup to lead them to deep playoff contention.

Conclusion: The Backup QB's Importance

The role of the backup quarterback is often overlooked. However, as we've explored, these players can be the difference between a successful season and an early exit from the playoffs. Their readiness, talent, and the team's overall strength determine their potential impact. Keep your eye on these players in 2024; they may just be the key to an unforgettable playoff run. What do you think? Which backup QB will surprise us the most in the upcoming season? Share your predictions in the comments below!