Ranking The Best Backup QBs: Contenders For A 2024 NFL Playoff Run

David

3 min read

Post on Jun 14, 2025

4.2

Share

Ranking the Best Backup QBs: Contenders for a 2024 NFL Playoff Run

The NFL season is a marathon, not a sprint, and even the most robust starting quarterbacks are susceptible to injury. A team's playoff hopes often hinge on the competence of their backup. So, as the 2024 season approaches, let's rank some of the league's best backup quarterbacks who could potentially lead their teams to a playoff run should the starter go down. This isn't just about arm strength; it's about leadership, experience, and game management under pressure.

Methodology: This ranking considers several factors, including past performance, experience in crucial game situations, familiarity with the team's offensive system, and overall perceived readiness to step into a starting role. We're looking for quarterbacks who inspire confidence, not just those with impressive stats on the bench.

Tier 1: The Elite Reserves

1. Brock Purdy (San Francisco 49ers): Purdy's remarkable late-season surge in 2022, despite being a late-round draft pick, catapults him to the top of this list. His composure and surprising accuracy make him a legitimate threat to lead a playoff push. His familiarity with Kyle Shanahan's system is a huge advantage. However, his injury history remains a concern.

2. Cooper Rush (Dallas Cowboys): A consistent performer in limited opportunities, Rush has proven he can win games for the Cowboys. His experience within the Cowboys' system and his calm demeanor under pressure make him a valuable asset. He’s a known commodity, and that’s invaluable in a crisis.

Tier 2: Solid Contributors with Upside

3. Gardner Minshew (Indianapolis Colts): Minshew’s energetic style and proven ability to extend plays make him a compelling backup option. His experience as a starter gives him an edge, although his consistency needs further demonstration.

4. Will Grier (Dallas Cowboys): While less experienced than Rush, Grier possesses a strong arm and the potential to develop into a capable starter. His progression within the Cowboys' organization will be key to his ranking next year.

5. Bailey Zappe (New England Patriots): Zappe showed flashes of potential in his limited appearances, showcasing a strong arm and decent decision-making. His development under Bill Belichick will determine his future status.

Tier 3: Potential but Untested

This tier includes quarterbacks with limited NFL experience, whose potential remains largely untapped. Their ranking depends heavily on their performance in upcoming preseason games and training camp. Examples might include several high-profile recent draft picks currently serving as backups.

The Importance of Backup QB Development

Investing in strong backup quarterbacks is crucial for NFL teams aiming for a Super Bowl run. Teams like the 49ers, with their commitment to developing quarterbacks at all levels, understand this. Regular practice reps, meaningful playing time in pre-season, and a strong coaching staff are essential for grooming a capable understudy. This investment isn’t just about insurance; it’s about maximizing the team's potential for success.

Looking Ahead: This ranking is a snapshot in time. The performance of these quarterbacks during the upcoming season, as well as the emergence of other potential backups, will significantly impact next year's rankings. Keep an eye on training camp battles and preseason games for updates on this crucial position. Who will emerge as the top backup in 2025? Only time will tell. Check back with us next year for an updated ranking!