Ranking The Best Backup QBs: 2024 NFL Playoff Dark Horses Revealed

David

3 min read

Post on May 28, 2025

4.2

Share

Ranking the Best Backup QBs: 2024 NFL Playoff Dark Horses Revealed

The NFL season is a marathon, not a sprint, and injuries are an inevitable part of the game. While star quarterbacks grab the headlines, the unsung heroes – the backup quarterbacks – can often be the difference between a playoff berth and an early offseason. This year, several teams boast backup QBs with the potential to elevate their teams to unexpected playoff contention, potentially becoming genuine 2024 NFL playoff dark horses. Let's rank the top contenders and explore why they could be the surprise factor this season.

The Top 5 Backup QBs Poised for Playoff Glory

This ranking considers a combination of factors: experience, recent performance, system fit, and the overall strength of their respective teams.

1. Brock Purdy (San Francisco 49ers): Purdy's performance before his injury last season was nothing short of remarkable. His quick release, accurate throws, and surprisingly adept leadership abilities proved he can handle the pressure of a high-stakes environment. While his recovery is key, if healthy, Purdy could seamlessly step in for Trey Lance and keep the 49ers' Super Bowl aspirations alive. His familiarity with the Kyle Shanahan offense is a massive advantage.

2. Cooper Rush (Dallas Cowboys): Rush has proven he can win games in the NFL. His experience within the Cowboys' system and his ability to manage the game effectively make him a reliable option behind Dak Prescott. While not a high-ceiling QB, his consistency and understanding of the offense give Dallas a safety net if Prescott suffers an injury.

3. Gardner Minshew II (Indianapolis Colts): Minshew brings a unique energy and a willingness to extend plays, traits that could electrify a Colts offense potentially lacking dynamism. His experience as a starter gives him an edge over other backups. The Colts’ success, however, hinges significantly on their running game and defense supporting Minshew.

4. Jordan Love (Green Bay Packers): Love finally gets his chance to prove himself after years of sitting behind Aaron Rodgers. While he has limited game experience, the Packers’ coaching staff is confident in his abilities, and his arm talent is undeniable. If Love can quickly adapt to the pressures of being a starting quarterback, the Packers could be a more competitive team than many anticipate. This situation, however, presents a considerable risk/reward dynamic.

5. Teddy Bridgewater (Miami Dolphins): Bridgewater’s extensive experience and calm demeanor under pressure make him a valuable asset for the Dolphins. While not a flashy player, his steady hand and game management skills could keep Miami competitive if Tua Tagovailoa suffers any setbacks.

Why Backup QBs Matter More Than Ever

The increased emphasis on offensive innovation and the prevalence of spread offenses have made finding capable backup QBs even more crucial. These quarterbacks need to be more than just game managers; they need to possess the skills to execute a complex playbook and adapt to various game situations. A strong backup can significantly impact a team's playoff chances, often turning a potential collapse into a compelling postseason run.

The X-Factor: Team Chemistry and Coaching

Beyond individual talent, a backup quarterback's success often depends on the team's overall strength and the coaching staff's ability to adapt their game plan. A strong running game and a dominant defense can significantly ease the burden on a backup quarterback, allowing them to focus on managing the game effectively.

The 2024 NFL season promises to be exciting, and these backup quarterbacks are poised to play a significant role. Keep an eye on these players; they could be the key to an unexpected playoff run for their teams. Who do you think will be the biggest surprise? Let us know in the comments below!