Ranking The Best Backup NFL Quarterbacks For A 2024 Playoff Run

David

3 min read

Post on May 13, 2025

4.7

Share

Ranking the Best Backup NFL Quarterbacks for a 2024 Playoff Run

The NFL playoffs are a brutal crucible. One injury, one unexpected slump, and a team's Super Bowl dreams can vanish faster than a Lamar Jackson scramble. That's why having a reliable backup quarterback is paramount. This year, the gap between starters and backups feels wider than ever. But who among the league's understudies possesses the skills and experience to steer a team to victory in the pressure cooker of January football? Let's rank the best backup quarterbacks primed to make a difference in the 2024 NFL Playoffs.

Methodology: This ranking considers a combination of factors: past performance, experience in crucial game situations, arm talent, and overall system fit. We're not just looking at raw stats; we're assessing the potential to step in and immediately stabilize a team's offense.

Tier 1: The Elite Understudies

1. Brock Purdy (San Francisco 49ers): Purdy's improbable run in 2022, culminating in a strong playoff performance before injury, catapults him to the top. His poise under pressure, combined with his understanding of Kyle Shanahan's intricate offense, makes him exceptionally valuable. He’s shown he can win big games, and the 49ers' system is designed to maximize a quarterback's strengths, even those of a less experienced player.

2. Cooper Rush (Dallas Cowboys): Rush has consistently proven himself as a capable game manager for the Cowboys, demonstrating reliability and a knack for winning games when called upon. While not possessing the high-ceiling arm talent of some others on this list, his experience and familiarity with the Cowboys' offense make him a valuable asset. He's a perfect example of a quarterback who understands his role and executes it flawlessly. [Link to Cowboys' official website]

Tier 2: Solid Contributors with High Potential

3. Gardner Minshew (Indianapolis Colts): Minshew's gunslinger mentality and improvisational skills could be a wild card for any team. His experience as a starter gives him an edge over many backups. He brings a level of excitement and potential that could ignite an offense if given the opportunity. However, his consistency needs improvement for him to climb higher.

4. Will Grier (Dallas Cowboys): Grier's experience within the Cowboys system and familiarity with Kellen Moore's offensive approach might give him an edge in a sudden situation. However, limited game time means his ability to perform under intense playoff pressure remains largely untested.

Tier 3: Promising Young Guns with Room to Grow

5. Jake Luton (Jacksonville Jaguars): Luton has shown flashes of talent, but limited NFL experience places him lower on the list. His potential is undeniable, and with more time and development, he could move up the rankings in the future. However, for the 2024 playoffs, he remains a higher-risk option.

Factors Affecting Backup QB Value

Several factors beyond individual talent determine a backup's worth:

• Offensive Scheme: A quarterback's success is heavily influenced by the offensive system. A simpler, more run-heavy scheme might better suit a less experienced backup than a complex, pass-heavy attack.
• Coaching Staff: A strong coaching staff can help a backup quarterback adjust quickly and effectively.
• Offensive Line Protection: A solid offensive line is critical for any quarterback, especially a backup stepping into a high-pressure situation.

Conclusion: While no backup can perfectly replicate a star quarterback's performance, the difference between a competent backup and a liability can be the difference between a playoff run and an early exit. The teams with the top backups on this list are in a significantly stronger position heading into the 2024 season. The upcoming season will be crucial in further shaping the rankings and revealing which backup quarterbacks can rise to the occasion under the bright lights of the NFL Playoffs.

Call to Action: Who do you think is the most underrated backup quarterback heading into 2024? Let us know in the comments below!