NHL Playoffs: Oilers Opt For Pickard In Net For Crucial Game 5 Vs. Panthers

David

3 min read

Post on Jun 16, 2025

4.6

Share

NHL Playoffs: Oilers Roll the Dice, Start Pickard in Net for Crucial Game 5 vs. Panthers

The Edmonton Oilers are taking a gamble. Facing elimination in Game 5 of their second-round playoff series against the Florida Panthers, the Oilers have opted for the unexpected: veteran goaltender Laurent Brossoit will be scratched, and Jack Campbell will be the backup. Instead, it's journeyman netminder, Stuart Skinner's understudy, Laurent Pickard who will start between the pipes. This bold move has sent shockwaves through the hockey world, raising questions about the Oilers' strategy and the health of their goaltending situation.

The decision comes after a shaky performance from starter Stuart Skinner in Game 4, where the Panthers stormed back from a two-goal deficit to win 4-2 and even the series at 2-2. Skinner allowed four goals on 27 shots, leaving Oilers fans and analysts questioning his ability to consistently perform under pressure in the high-stakes environment of the NHL Playoffs.

<h3>A High-Stakes Gamble: Why Pickard?</h3>

The Oilers' coaching staff hasn't publicly commented on the reasoning behind the surprising decision to start Pickard, a move that leaves many wondering about the true state of Skinner’s health and the team's confidence in their current goaltending options. While Pickard has limited NHL experience, he's known for his calm demeanor and solid fundamentals. This could be a strategic choice to provide a different look in net, hoping to disrupt the Panthers' offensive rhythm.

• Experience Matters: While Pickard lacks extensive playoff experience, his time in the AHL and brief NHL stints have prepared him for the intensity of the postseason. His familiarity with the Oilers' defensive system could be a crucial factor.
• A Change of Pace: The move could be designed to inject a spark into the Oilers’ game. A fresh face in net might unsettle the Panthers’ attack and energize the Edmonton team.
• Injury Concerns? Speculation is rife about potential injuries to both Skinner and Campbell. The Oilers' silence fuels these rumors, leaving fans anxiously awaiting clarification.

<h3>Pickard's Career and Potential Impact</h3>

Laurent Pickard, 33, has bounced around the NHL and AHL for much of his career, displaying flashes of brilliance but also struggling with consistency. His statistics aren't dazzling, but his experience against NHL-caliber talent could prove valuable in this crucial Game 5. Will this be his breakout moment on the grand stage? The pressure is undoubtedly immense.

This move represents a significant risk for the Oilers. A loss could send them crashing out of the playoffs, while a win would inject vital momentum and confidence into the team. The pressure is on Pickard to perform beyond expectations.

<h3>What's Next for the Oilers?</h3>

The Oilers' Game 5 performance will heavily influence how the narrative around this bold goalie choice unfolds. A victory would be seen as a stroke of genius, while a defeat would lead to intense scrutiny of the coaching staff's decision-making. Regardless of the outcome, the Oilers' gamble on Laurent Pickard will be a memorable moment in the 2023 NHL Playoffs. This unexpected development has certainly elevated the drama and stakes for this crucial series.

Stay tuned for updates and analysis following Game 5! Let us know your thoughts in the comments below.