NFL Week 2 Fantasy Football: Weighing The Start/Sit Options For McLaurin And McMillan

David

3 min read

Post on Sep 12, 2025

4.1

Share

NFL Week 2 Fantasy Football: McLaurin or McMillan – Who Starts?

Fantasy football managers everywhere are grappling with tough decisions in Week 2, and two names consistently popping up in start/sit debates are Terry McLaurin and Khalil Herbert. Both players offer intriguing potential, but their matchups and recent performances leave many owners questioning who deserves a spot in their starting lineup. This article will delve into the key factors influencing these decisions, helping you make informed choices for your fantasy team.

Terry McLaurin: High Ceiling, But High Risk?

McLaurin, the Washington Commanders' top receiver, carries a significant fantasy football pedigree. However, his Week 1 performance was underwhelming, leaving many fantasy owners hesitant. He was targeted only six times, resulting in a relatively low fantasy output. The Commanders' offensive struggles are a significant concern.

• The Case for Starting McLaurin: McLaurin is undoubtedly the Commanders' go-to receiver. Even with a struggling offense, his talent and volume of targets make him a potential boom-or-bust player. A strong performance from quarterback Sam Howell could unlock McLaurin's high ceiling. A favorable matchup against a weaker secondary could significantly boost his chances of a big game.

• The Case Against Starting McLaurin: The Commanders' offense remains a major question mark. Their lack of consistency could limit McLaurin's opportunities. If Howell continues to struggle, McLaurin's fantasy output could be severely impacted. A tough matchup against a strong defense would further diminish his chances of a successful week. Consider checking the latest injury reports as well, as any injury concerns would significantly impact his viability.

Khalil Herbert: The Chicago Bears' Reliable Rusher?

Herbert, the Chicago Bears' running back, provided a steady performance in Week 1, showcasing his ability to contribute consistently. While he may not have the explosive potential of some other running backs, his reliability makes him a valuable asset in fantasy football.

• The Case for Starting Herbert: Herbert offers a floor of points. Even in games where the Bears' offense struggles, he's likely to receive a decent number of carries. His consistency and receiving ability make him a relatively safe start. A favourable matchup could easily see Herbert exceed expectations.

• The Case Against Starting Herbert: Herbert is not a high-ceiling player. He's unlikely to break off many long runs, limiting his potential for explosive fantasy performances. The emergence of another running back could impact his snap share and therefore reduce his fantasy output. Keep a close eye on the Bears' game plan and the health of other key players.

Making the Call: McLaurin vs. McMillan

Ultimately, the decision of whether to start McLaurin or Herbert depends heavily on your risk tolerance and the rest of your roster. If you need a high-ceiling player who could potentially win you the week, McLaurin is your choice, but be prepared for potential disappointment. If you prefer a safer, more reliable option who will consistently provide points, Herbert is the better pick.

Beyond the Stats: Factors to Consider

Remember to consider these additional factors when making your decision:

• Matchup: Analyze the opposing defenses' performance against receivers and running backs.
• Injury Reports: Stay updated on injury news that could impact either player's availability or effectiveness.
• Team Performance: Consider the overall offensive performance of both the Commanders and the Bears.
• Your Roster: Evaluate your other options and your overall team needs.

Making the right start/sit decision is crucial for success in fantasy football. By carefully weighing the pros and cons of each player and considering these additional factors, you'll be better equipped to make informed decisions that will hopefully lead to victory. Good luck in Week 2!