NFL Week 2 Fantasy Football: Weighing The Start/Sit Decision For McLaurin & McMillan

David

3 min read

Post on Sep 12, 2025

4.4

Share

NFL Week 2 Fantasy Football: The McLaurin & McMillan Start/Sit Dilemma

Week 1 of the NFL season is in the books, leaving fantasy football managers scrambling to adjust their lineups for Week 2. This week presents a particularly tricky decision for many: start or sit Terry McLaurin and Khalil Herbert? Both players offer intriguing potential, but also carry significant risk. Let's dive into the factors to consider before making your crucial Week 2 lineup decisions.

Terry McLaurin: Commanders' Offensive Uncertainty

McLaurin, a perennial fantasy football favorite, faces a tough situation heading into Week 2. While his talent is undeniable, the Commanders' offensive performance in Week 1 left much to be desired. Sam Howell's debut wasn't exactly a masterpiece, raising concerns about the team's overall offensive efficiency and McLaurin's target share.

• The Positive: McLaurin remains a focal point in the Commanders' passing game, and his deep-threat ability always makes him a touchdown threat. A bounce-back game from Howell is certainly possible.

• The Negative: The Commanders face a tougher opponent in Week 2. A strong defense could limit McLaurin's opportunities, leading to a disappointing fantasy performance. His low target volume in Week 1 is a significant red flag.

Should you start McLaurin? The answer is nuanced. In deeper leagues, or if you're desperate for a WR2, he might be worth the risk. However, in shallower leagues with better alternatives, it might be wiser to explore other options. Consider his matchup and the Commanders' overall offensive outlook before making your final decision.

Khalil Herbert: A Chicago Bears Backfield Logjam?

The Chicago Bears' backfield situation is a constant source of fantasy frustration. While David Montgomery is the presumed starter, Khalil Herbert proved his value in Week 1, showcasing his explosive playmaking ability. However, the committee approach remains a significant concern.

• The Positive: Herbert's big-play potential is undeniable. He can break off a long run at any moment, offering a high ceiling in fantasy scoring. If Montgomery struggles or is injured, Herbert could become a workhorse back.

• The Negative: The uncertainty regarding touches makes him a risky start. A committee approach limits his overall fantasy production predictability. His performance is entirely dependent on how the Bears utilize their running backs.

Should you start Herbert? This is another tough call. If you're in a PPR league and need a reliable pass-catching back, Herbert might not be the best option. However, in standard leagues, his touchdown upside makes him a tempting flex play, especially if you're willing to accept the risk associated with a shared backfield. Keep a close eye on injury reports and the game script before making your decision.

Conclusion: Weighing the Risks and Rewards

Both McLaurin and Herbert present intriguing yet risky fantasy options in Week 2. Carefully consider their respective matchups, the overall offensive environments of their teams, and your other available roster options before making your start/sit decisions. Remember to check for late-breaking news and injury updates before finalizing your lineup. Good luck!

Further Reading:

• [Link to a reputable NFL news site for Week 2 fantasy football advice]
• [Link to a fantasy football expert's analysis of the Commanders' offense]
• [Link to a fantasy football expert's analysis of the Chicago Bears' backfield]

This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial or fantasy football advice. Always conduct your own research before making lineup decisions.