NFL 2024 Playoff Contenders: Ranking The Backup Quarterback Options

David

3 min read

Post on May 31, 2025

4.1

Share

NFL 2024 Playoff Contenders: Ranking the Backup Quarterback Options

The NFL regular season is a marathon, not a sprint. Even the most elite teams know that injuries are an inevitable part of the game, and the difference between a playoff berth and a disappointing season can often hinge on the performance of the backup quarterback. With the 2024 season looming, let's dive into a ranking of the backup QB situations for some of the top playoff contenders, analyzing their strengths and weaknesses and considering the potential impact on their postseason hopes.

The Elite Tier: Contenders with Solid Backup Plans

Several teams enter the season with backup quarterbacks who inspire confidence. These teams are better positioned to weather the storm of a starting quarterback injury.

1. Kansas City Chiefs: While the Chiefs' success rides heavily on Patrick Mahomes, they boast a capable backup in Blaine Gabbert. His experience and understanding of Andy Reid's system provide a level of comfort rarely seen in the league. Gabbert’s veteran presence offers stability should Mahomes face any setbacks.

2. Philadelphia Eagles: The Eagles' success last season highlighted the importance of a robust QB2. While their specific backup for 2024 remains to be seen, their history of smart roster construction suggests they'll have a reliable option in place. Their commitment to building depth at the position ensures they won’t be caught off guard by injury.

3. Buffalo Bills: The Bills, perennial contenders, usually have a strong backup plan. Their scouting and development of young quarterbacks often results in a solid, if not spectacular, second-string option. Expect them to have a capable quarterback ready to step up if Josh Allen faces any injury concerns.

The Middle Tier: Teams with Potential but Question Marks

This tier includes teams with backups who could perform adequately but face significant uncertainties.

1. Cincinnati Bengals: The Bengals' success hinges heavily on Joe Burrow. Their backup situation needs to improve. A strong showing in the preseason will be critical to assessing their preparedness for a potential quarterback injury.

2. San Francisco 49ers: The 49ers' quarterback situation is always a topic of conversation. While they have a talented roster, the uncertainty at the backup QB position needs to be addressed to guarantee consistent playoff contention.

The Concerning Tier: Teams with Significant Backup Concerns

These teams face considerable risk if their starting quarterbacks suffer injuries.

1. Dallas Cowboys: The Cowboys’ success is heavily reliant on Dak Prescott. A significant injury to Prescott could severely derail their playoff hopes, given the concerns about the depth behind him. Addressing this weakness should be a priority.

2. Baltimore Ravens: Lamar Jackson's health is paramount to the Ravens' success. The team needs a more reliable backup plan to confidently navigate the season and maintain their playoff aspirations.

Beyond the Starters: The Importance of Backup QBs

The impact of a quality backup quarterback can’t be overstated. A capable QB2 offers:

• Continuity: Maintaining offensive schemes and play calls.
• Stability: Providing a sense of calm and confidence to the team.
• Reduced Risk: Minimizing the impact of injuries on playoff chances.

The upcoming season will showcase how well these teams have addressed the crucial role of the backup quarterback. Stay tuned for the unfolding drama and the vital contributions (or lack thereof) from these second-string players. Their performance could very well determine the fate of several playoff contenders in 2024. What are your thoughts? Share your predictions in the comments below!