MLB Trade Grades: Did The Yankees Improve With The McMahon Deal? (2025)

David

3 min read

Post on Jul 27, 2025

4.2

Share

MLB Trade Grades: Did the Yankees Improve with the McMahon Deal? (2025)

The 2025 MLB trade deadline saw the New York Yankees make a surprising move, acquiring highly touted pitching prospect, Jake McMahon, from the Chicago Cubs. While the Yankees’ playoff hopes hung precariously in the balance, this deal sparked intense debate among fans and analysts alike. Did the Yankees bolster their roster, or did they overpay for a player still proving himself at the major league level? Let's dive into the trade grades and assess the impact of this acquisition.

The Trade Breakdown:

To acquire McMahon, the Yankees reportedly sent a package including highly-rated shortstop prospect, Anthony Volpe, and veteran reliever, Clay Holmes, to the Cubs. This immediately raised eyebrows, given Volpe's potential and Holmes’ proven effectiveness in high-leverage situations. The Cubs, rebuilding their farm system, clearly saw this as a worthwhile gamble.

Analyzing the Yankees' Perspective:

• Gaining McMahon: McMahon, a 23-year-old right-hander, possesses a fastball that consistently registers in the mid-90s mph and a devastating slider. Scouts project him as a potential front-of-the-rotation starter, a significant need for the Yankees. His acquisition addresses a critical weakness in their pitching depth, providing much-needed firepower for a potential playoff run. This addresses a key concern for the Yankees in 2025: securing reliable pitching depth.

• Losing Volpe and Holmes: The loss of Volpe, a top prospect with star potential, is undeniably a hefty price to pay. However, the Yankees' front office clearly prioritized immediate contention over long-term development. Holmes, a reliable reliever, will also be missed. The cost of this trade is significant, making the assessment more complex.

Grading the Trade:

Giving the Yankees a definitive grade is challenging. It's a high-risk, high-reward scenario.

• Pros: McMahon's potential to become a top-tier starter offers a significant upgrade to the Yankees' pitching staff. A healthy and successful McMahon could be a game-changer in the postseason.
• Cons: The cost of Volpe and Holmes is substantial. If McMahon doesn't live up to expectations, this trade will be remembered as a major misstep. The long-term impact on the Yankees' farm system also warrants serious consideration.

Early Verdict: A Risky B+

While the upside is immense, the risk associated with this trade is undeniable. We've given the Yankees a B+ grade for now. This is a risky move, with the potential for significant rewards, but the cost may prove too high if McMahon doesn't pan out. Only time will tell if this trade will be viewed as a stroke of genius or a costly mistake. The success of this trade hinges entirely on McMahon’s performance in the upcoming seasons.

Looking Ahead:

The coming season will be crucial in evaluating the success of this trade. McMahon's performance and the Yankees' postseason run will directly impact the long-term perception of this deal. The impact on the Yankees’ farm system will also be a key factor to consider.

What are your thoughts on the McMahon trade? Share your opinions in the comments below!

Keywords: MLB Trade, Yankees, Cubs, Jake McMahon, Anthony Volpe, Clay Holmes, MLB Trade Deadline, 2025 MLB Season, Baseball Trade Analysis, MLB Trade Grades, Baseball Prospect, New York Yankees, Chicago Cubs, MLB Rumors.