MLB All-Star 2025: Projected Lineups & Biggest Roster Debates

David

3 min read

Post on Jun 17, 2025

4.7

Share

MLB All-Star 2025: Projected Lineups & Biggest Roster Debates

The 2024 MLB season is still in full swing, but baseball fans are already looking ahead to the 2025 All-Star Game. Predicting lineups this far out is a risky business, but based on current performance and projected trajectories, we can begin to speculate on the potential rosters and the intense debates they'll spark. This year's game promises to be a clash of titans, with several key positions facing fierce competition.

Projected Starting Lineups (American League & National League):

Creating projected lineups this far in advance requires acknowledging the inherent uncertainty of baseball. Injuries, slumps, and unexpected breakouts can dramatically alter the landscape. However, based on current form and future potential, here are some potential starting lineups for both leagues in 2025:

American League:

• C: Adley Rutschman (Orioles) – Rutschman's defensive prowess and growing offensive power make him a near-lock.
• 1B: Vladimir Guerrero Jr. (Blue Jays) – Assuming he continues his offensive dominance.
• 2B: Bobby Witt Jr. (Royals) – A rising star with both power and speed.
• SS: Wander Franco (Rays) – A potential generational talent if he can stay healthy.
• 3B: José Ramírez (Guardians) – A consistent All-Star performer.
• LF: Mike Trout (Angels) – If healthy, Trout is a perennial All-Star.
• CF: Julio Rodríguez (Mariners) – Already an All-Star, Rodriguez's future is incredibly bright.
• RF: Aaron Judge (Yankees) – Power hitting is his specialty, and he'll likely continue to excel.
• DH: Shohei Ohtani (Angels) – The two-way superstar is a guaranteed selection.

National League:

• C: Will Smith (Dodgers) – A consistent performer behind the plate.
• 1B: Freddie Freeman (Dodgers) – A veteran presence and batting champion.
• 2B: Luis Arraez (Marlins) – His batting average is consistently high.
• SS: Dansby Swanson (Cubs) – A strong defensive player with solid offensive contributions.
• 3B: Nolan Arenado (Cardinals) – Another consistent All-Star, known for his defense.
• LF: Juan Soto (Padres) – His plate discipline and power make him a crucial asset.
• CF: Michael Harris II (Braves) – A young and exciting player with five-tool potential.
• RF: Mookie Betts (Dodgers) – A proven All-Star and valuable player.

Biggest Roster Debates:

While the above projections offer a glimpse into potential lineups, several positions are ripe for debate:

• American League Shortstop: While Wander Franco is projected to start, other young stars like Anthony Volpe (Yankees) and Gunnar Henderson (Orioles) could challenge for a spot. The competition will be fierce.
• National League Third Base: While Nolan Arenado is a likely selection, other players like Austin Riley (Braves) and Alec Bohm (Phillies) could make strong cases for inclusion. Their power and performance will play a key role.
• Catcher (Both Leagues): The catcher position in both leagues is full of talented players, meaning there will be a lot of competition to earn a roster spot.
• Starting Pitchers: Selecting the starting pitchers will be a difficult decision, with many deserving candidates from both leagues. This is always a hot topic of conversation leading up to the All-Star Game.

Conclusion:

The 2025 MLB All-Star Game is still some time away, but the potential matchups and roster battles are already generating excitement. While injuries and unexpected performances can alter these projections drastically, the anticipation for this clash of baseball's finest is palpable. Keep an eye on the developing seasons of 2024 and 2025 to see how these projections hold up! What are your thoughts? Share your predictions in the comments below!