Hill Ranks His Top Five QBs: Tua Tagovailoa Notably Absent

David

3 min read

Post on May 08, 2025

4.2

Share

Hill Ranks His Top Five QBs: Tua Tagovailoa's Absence Sparks Debate

Controversial NFL Analyst Steve Hill's recent top-five quarterback ranking has ignited a firestorm of debate among football fans, most notably due to the glaring omission of Miami Dolphins quarterback Tua Tagovailoa. The list, released yesterday on his popular podcast "Hill's Huddle," has sparked intense discussion across social media platforms and sports forums. While some agree with Hill's selections, many are questioning his criteria and the conspicuous absence of the rising star, Tua.

Hill's ranking, prioritizing established veterans and statistically dominant players, placed Patrick Mahomes at the top spot, followed by Josh Allen, Joe Burrow, Jalen Hurts, and Justin Herbert. This selection, while representing some of the league's elite talent, has left many feeling Hill's assessment is incomplete and perhaps even biased.

The Tua Tagovailoa Question: Skill vs. Durability?

The most significant point of contention revolves around Tua Tagovailoa's exclusion. While acknowledging Tagovailoa's undeniable talent and impressive statistics in certain games, Hill cited concerns surrounding the quarterback's injury history as the primary reason for his omission. "While Tua has shown flashes of brilliance," Hill stated on his podcast, "his susceptibility to concussions and other injuries casts a significant shadow over his long-term potential and consistency."

This argument, however, has been met with considerable backlash. Many argue that Hill's focus on durability overshadows Tagovailoa's demonstrable skill and the progress he's made in recent seasons. Supporters point to Tagovailoa's improved accuracy, increased yards per attempt, and his ability to lead the Dolphins to playoff contention as evidence of his growth and undeniable talent.

A Look at Hill's Top Five: A Fair Assessment?

Let's examine Hill's top five picks more closely:

• Patrick Mahomes (Kansas City Chiefs): Undisputed top-tier talent, consistently delivering MVP-caliber performances.
• Josh Allen (Buffalo Bills): A powerful, dual-threat quarterback known for his exceptional arm strength and running ability.
• Joe Burrow (Cincinnati Bengals): A cool-headed leader with a knack for clutch performances and an impressive ability to read defenses.
• Jalen Hurts (Philadelphia Eagles): A dynamic quarterback showcasing a potent blend of passing and rushing skills.
• Justin Herbert (Los Angeles Chargers): Possessing a cannon for an arm, Herbert consistently delivers explosive plays.

While these quarterbacks are undoubtedly exceptional, the exclusion of Tagovailoa from the top five, even considering his injury history, remains a contentious issue for many NFL analysts and fans alike.

The Debate Continues: Where Does Tua Truly Rank?

The debate surrounding Tua Tagovailoa's ranking highlights the subjective nature of evaluating quarterbacks. Statistics, while important, don't fully capture the nuances of leadership, resilience, and the intangible factors that contribute to success. Ultimately, Tagovailoa's future performance and continued health will play a significant role in shaping future rankings and solidifying his place among the NFL's elite. The conversation continues, and only time will tell if Hill's assessment holds up.

What are your thoughts? Where would you rank Tua Tagovailoa among the top quarterbacks in the NFL? Share your opinion in the comments below!