Hill Ranks His Top Five QBs: Tua Tagovailoa Left Off The List

David

3 min read

Post on May 08, 2025

4.9

Share

Hill Ranks His Top Five QBs: Tua Tagovailoa's Absence Sparks Debate

Colin Cowherd's recent ranking of the NFL's top quarterbacks has ignited a firestorm of debate, particularly due to the conspicuous absence of Miami Dolphins quarterback Tua Tagovailoa. The list, compiled by sports analyst Colin Cowherd, has sparked intense discussions among fans and analysts alike, prompting questions about Tagovailoa's current standing in the league and the criteria used for the rankings.

Cowherd's top five, revealed on his popular radio show and podcast, featured a mix of established veterans and rising stars. While the specific order remains a point of contention amongst viewers, the overall omission of Tagovailoa is the most controversial aspect. This exclusion has raised eyebrows, considering Tagovailoa’s impressive performance in recent seasons, particularly his improved efficiency and leadership under head coach Mike McDaniel.

Cowherd's Controversial Top 5 (Order Unspecified)

While the exact order remains debated, Cowherd's top 5 reportedly included (but isn't limited to) these quarterbacks:

• Patrick Mahomes (Kansas City Chiefs): A perennial MVP contender and Super Bowl champion, Mahomes' inclusion is unsurprising. His consistent high-level performance solidifies his position among the league's elite.
• Josh Allen (Buffalo Bills): Allen's powerful arm and dynamic playmaking ability make him a consistently strong candidate for any top QB list. His consistent playoff appearances further cement his status.
• Joe Burrow (Cincinnati Bengals): Burrow's leadership and clutch performances, particularly in the playoffs, have earned him a spot among the league's best. His Super Bowl appearance further validates his place.
• Jalen Hurts (Philadelphia Eagles): Hurts' exceptional dual-threat abilities and Super Bowl appearance have propelled him into the elite QB conversation. His impressive rushing and passing stats support his inclusion.
• Justin Herbert (Los Angeles Chargers): Herbert's impressive arm talent and consistent production place him firmly in the conversation of top NFL quarterbacks. However, playoff success remains a key factor for many analysts.

Why the Tua Tagovailoa Snub Matters

Tagovailoa's exclusion is particularly noteworthy given his significant strides in 2022. He displayed improved accuracy, decision-making, and leadership under McDaniel's offensive system. Many analysts point to his impressive completion percentage and reduced interceptions as evidence of his growth and potential. However, critics often cite his injury history as a significant factor impacting his overall ranking.

The debate surrounding Tagovailoa's ranking highlights the subjective nature of quarterback evaluations. While statistics play a crucial role, factors like playoff success, durability, and overall team performance often influence these rankings. This highlights the inherent complexities in comparing quarterbacks across different teams and offensive schemes.

The Ongoing Debate: Is Tua Underrated?

The omission of Tua Tagovailoa from Colin Cowherd's top five has sparked a vigorous online debate. Many fans and analysts argue that Tagovailoa's consistent improvement and impressive statistical performance warrant inclusion. Others maintain that his injury history and lack of extensive playoff experience justify his exclusion. The conversation underscores the inherent difficulty in objectively ranking NFL quarterbacks and the various factors that contribute to a player's overall evaluation.

This situation perfectly exemplifies the ever-evolving nature of NFL power rankings. Will Tua Tagovailoa silence his critics in the upcoming season? Only time will tell. What are your thoughts on this controversial ranking? Share your opinions in the comments below!