Hill Ranks His Top Five QBs: Tua Left Off The List

3 min read Post on May 08, 2025

Hill Ranks His Top Five QBs: Tua Left Off The List

Hill Ranks His Top Five QBs: Tua Tagovailoa's Absence Sparks Debate

Controversial rankings ignite NFL discussions as Colin Cowherd's colleague, Chris "Mad Dog" Russo, omits Tua Tagovailoa from his top five quarterbacks. The NFL offseason is always a whirlwind of speculation, but this year, a particularly fiery debate has erupted thanks to sports commentator Chris "Mad Dog" Russo's recent ranking of his top five quarterbacks. Notably absent from the list? Miami Dolphins star Tua Tagovailoa, a decision that has sent shockwaves through the football world and ignited passionate discussions amongst fans and analysts alike.

Russo, known for his outspoken opinions and fiery debates alongside Colin Cowherd on "The Herd," unveiled his controversial list during a recent episode. While the exact reasoning behind the exclusion of Tagovailoa remains somewhat unclear, the omission has sparked widespread criticism and calls for a re-evaluation. Many argue that Tagovailoa's impressive 2022 season, despite injury concerns, warrants a place among the league's elite.

Russo's Top Five QBs: A Breakdown

While Russo hasn't explicitly detailed his reasoning, his top five likely reflects a combination of recent performance, career trajectory, and perceived potential. The exact order may vary based on the specific broadcast, but the quarterbacks generally included are:

Patrick Mahomes (Kansas City Chiefs): A perennial MVP candidate and Super Bowl champion, Mahomes' inclusion is unsurprising. His consistent excellence and dynamic playmaking abilities solidify his position at the top for many analysts.
Josh Allen (Buffalo Bills): Allen's powerful arm and rushing ability make him a force to be reckoned with. His consistent playoff appearances also bolster his claim to a top-five spot.
Joe Burrow (Cincinnati Bengals): Burrow's leadership and clutch performances have propelled the Bengals to consecutive AFC Championship games, earning him a place amongst the elite.
Jalen Hurts (Philadelphia Eagles): Hurts' remarkable dual-threat capabilities and Super Bowl appearance firmly place him in the conversation of the league's best quarterbacks.
Justin Herbert (Los Angeles Chargers): Herbert's impressive arm strength and accuracy, despite inconsistencies from his team, warrant consideration in the top five.

The Tua Tagovailoa Question: Why the Snub?

The glaring omission of Tua Tagovailoa from Russo's list is the source of much contention. Tagovailoa's 2022 season saw him throw for over 3,500 yards and 25 touchdowns, leading the Dolphins to a playoff berth. While concussion concerns understandably cast a shadow, his on-field performance undeniably demonstrates elite-level potential. Many speculate that Russo’s ranking might be influenced by Tagovailoa’s injury history, a factor some argue overshadows his undeniable talent.

Fan Reactions and Expert Opinions

Social media has exploded with reactions to Russo's list. Fans have expressed their disbelief and frustration, while many analysts have weighed in, defending or challenging Russo's choices. The debate highlights the subjective nature of ranking quarterbacks, with various factors – statistics, playoff success, injury history, and even perceived leadership qualities – all playing a role.

The Importance of Context in QB Rankings

It's crucial to remember that quarterback rankings are inherently subjective and often depend on the criteria used. While statistics are important, factors like team performance, coaching, and even luck play significant roles in a quarterback's overall success. Russo's list, therefore, should be viewed as one opinion amongst many, stimulating debate rather than representing a definitive truth.

What are your thoughts on Russo's rankings? Do you agree with the exclusion of Tua Tagovailoa? Share your opinions in the comments below!