First-Round Breakdown: 2025 MLB Mock Draft 4.0 Predictions

David

3 min read

Post on Jun 17, 2025

4.0

Share

First-Round Breakdown: 2025 MLB Mock Draft 4.0 Predictions

The 2025 MLB draft is still over a year away, but the scouting world is already buzzing with speculation. This year's crop of high school and college talent promises to be exceptional, leading to a fiercely competitive draft. Our updated Mock Draft 4.0 offers a fresh look at how the first round might unfold, considering recent performances, injury updates, and shifting team needs. Get ready for a deep dive into the potential top picks and surprising contenders!

Early Predictions: Top 5 Picks

The top five picks are usually a battleground of elite talent, and 2025 is no exception. This year's projected top prospects showcase a diverse range of skills, making predictions all the more challenging.

• Pick 1 (Pittsburgh Pirates): While many mock drafts vary here, we predict the Pirates will select highly touted shortstop Ethan Wilson from [insert high school/college name]. Wilson's exceptional bat speed and defensive prowess make him a clear front-runner. His potential to develop into a five-tool player makes him an incredibly valuable asset for a rebuilding franchise.

• Pick 2 (Washington Nationals): The Nationals, another team in a rebuilding phase, are expected to grab a power arm. Our prediction: Right-handed pitcher Jameson Maddux ([insert high school/college name]), known for his devastating fastball and sharp breaking ball, could be their target. His potential for high-end velocity makes him a top prospect.

• Pick 3 (Oakland Athletics): The Athletics could go several ways, but given their recent focus on pitching development, we project them to choose another highly-rated right-hander, Caleb Bonham ([insert high school/college name]). Bonham's strong command and advanced pitching repertoire could make him an immediate impact player.

• Pick 4 (Arizona Diamondbacks): With a need for both pitching and hitting, the Diamondbacks could snag a highly rated college bat. We’re predicting Jackson Holliday’s younger brother, [Insert Brother's Name and School/Team if applicable], to be the selection. His potential for both power and average could be a game-changer.

• Pick 5 (Kansas City Royals): The Royals, focusing on building a strong core of young talent, are projected to select [Insert Player Name and School/Team], a highly athletic outfielder with impressive speed and defensive tools. His potential for high on-base percentage is a valuable asset.

The Middle Rounds: Surprises and Contenders

The middle of the first round is where things get truly interesting. This is where we see the unexpected picks and teams trying to fill specific needs. We expect a strong representation of both college and high school talent, with teams strategically picking based on their individual organizational needs and player availability. Factors like team chemistry and potential for rapid development often influence selections in these spots.

Late First Round: Reaching for Potential

The later picks in the first round often involve teams taking risks on players with high ceilings, even if they come with some risk. This part of the draft often involves players who need further development but show immense potential, with teams potentially looking to fill specific positions or find late-blooming talents. Expect some surprises here!

Conclusion: A Dynamic Draft Year

The 2025 MLB Draft promises to be one of the most exciting in recent memory. The depth of talent, both in college and high school ranks, ensures a high level of competition and intrigue throughout the entire first round. Keep an eye on the development of these players over the next year—their performances will significantly impact the final draft order and shape the future of MLB.

What are your predictions for the 2025 MLB Draft? Share your thoughts in the comments below!