Fantasy Football Week 2 Dilemma: McLaurin Or McMillan – Who Starts?

David

3 min read

Post on Sep 12, 2025

4.6

Share

Fantasy Football Week 2 Dilemma: McLaurin or McMillan – Who Starts?

Fantasy football managers everywhere are facing a tough decision this week: Terry McLaurin or James Conner? Both players offer significant potential, but choosing the right one for your lineup could be the difference between victory and defeat. This article breaks down the key factors to consider when making this crucial Week 2 decision.

The Commanders' wide receiver, Terry McLaurin, and the Cardinals' running back, James Conner, present compelling but contrasting fantasy profiles. Their performances in Week 1 paint a mixed picture, and upcoming matchups further complicate the choice. Let's dive into the details to help you make the best decision for your fantasy team.

McLaurin's Week 1 Performance and Upcoming Challenge:

McLaurin had a relatively quiet Week 1, hampered by the Commanders' offensive struggles against the Arizona Cardinals. He managed only 3 receptions for 36 yards – a far cry from his usual production. However, this performance shouldn't automatically disqualify him from your starting lineup. The Commanders' offense is expected to improve, and McLaurin remains a top target for quarterback Sam Howell. His matchup in Week 2, however, is a considerable factor.

• Consider this: McLaurin faces a tough defense in Week 2 against the Detroit Lions, known for their ability to pressure quarterbacks and limit big plays. This could again impact his production.

Conner's Week 1 Dominance and Favorable Matchup:

Conner, on the other hand, had a stellar Week 1, rushing for 78 yards and a touchdown against the Washington Commanders. He showed explosiveness and secured a significant role in Arizona's offense. This performance, combined with his upcoming matchup, makes him a highly attractive option.

• The advantage: Conner faces a more favorable matchup in Week 2 against the New Orleans Saints, a team that struggled against the run in their season opener. This significantly boosts Conner's potential for another strong performance.

Head-to-Head Comparison: McLaurin vs. Conner

The Verdict:

While McLaurin possesses a higher ceiling, the risk associated with his tough Week 2 matchup is substantial. Conner's more favorable matchup and consistent Week 1 performance give him a significant edge. For Week 2, James Conner appears to be the safer and more reliable start. However, consider your team's overall needs. If you need a higher-risk, higher-reward option and are comfortable with potential disappointment, McLaurin could be worth the gamble.

Remember: This analysis is based on available information at the time of writing. Always monitor injury reports and news leading up to game day to make the most informed decision. Good luck in Week 2! Need more fantasy football advice? Check out our [link to another relevant article on your site - e.g., Fantasy Football Week 2 Waiver Wire Targets].