Evaluating The 2019 NFL Draft: The Top 10 Performers

David

4 min read

Post on Jun 13, 2025

4.1

Share

Evaluating the 2019 NFL Draft: The Top 10 Performers Five Years Later

The 2019 NFL Draft, now five years in the rearview mirror, offers a fascinating case study in evaluating draft success. While early projections often miss the mark, some players have undeniably exceeded expectations, cementing their places among the league's elite. This article delves into the top 10 performers from the 2019 draft, examining their impact and highlighting the factors contributing to their success. We'll also consider some surprising underperformers and what we can learn from both sides of the coin.

Methodology: Our ranking considers a combination of factors including Pro Bowl selections, All-Pro honors, individual statistical achievements, team success, and overall impact on the game. It's important to note that this is a subjective evaluation, and reasonable arguments could be made for other players.

The Top 10 Performers:

1. Nick Bosa (DE, San Francisco 49ers): The #2 overall pick has lived up to the hype and then some. Bosa's consistent dominance, including a Defensive Player of the Year caliber season, solidifies his position at the top. His relentless pass rush and overall defensive prowess make him a cornerstone for any franchise.

2. Quinnen Williams (DT, New York Jets): Despite some early injury concerns, Williams has established himself as a disruptive force in the middle of the Jets' defense. His impact goes beyond statistics, showcasing a high level of talent and potential for even greater achievements.

3. Josh Allen (QB, Buffalo Bills): The seventh overall pick has transformed the Buffalo Bills into perennial contenders. His arm strength, accuracy, and improved decision-making have made him one of the NFL's top quarterbacks. Allen's leadership and clutch performances are key to Buffalo's success. [Link to Allen's career stats]

4. Montez Sweat (DE, Washington Commanders): Sweat has consistently delivered as a pass rusher, recording impressive sack numbers and impacting games with his athleticism. While injuries have hampered his consistency, his potential remains sky-high.

5. Devin White (LB, Tampa Bay Buccaneers): A tackling machine, White has quickly become a leader of the Buccaneers' defense. His speed and instincts allow him to make plays all over the field, showcasing his versatility as a linebacker.

6. DK Metcalf (WR, Seattle Seahawks): Known for his incredible athleticism and size, Metcalf has become a reliable deep threat for the Seahawks. His combination of speed and strength makes him a nightmare matchup for opposing cornerbacks.

7. Brian Burns (DE, Carolina Panthers): Burns’s relentless pursuit of the quarterback has made him a consistent threat in the Panthers' pass rush. His sack numbers consistently place him amongst the league's best.

8. Marquise Brown (WR, Baltimore Ravens/Arizona Cardinals): While initially seen as a deep threat specialist, Brown has broadened his game to become a more well-rounded receiver, showcasing improved route running and ball control. His impact varies based on the team he plays for.

9. A.J. Brown (WR, Tennessee Titans/Philadelphia Eagles): A big, physical receiver, Brown quickly established himself as a key target for the Titans and now the Eagles. His ability to make contested catches and consistently generate yards after the catch is impressive.

10. Greedy Williams (CB, Cleveland Browns): Although he has faced injury setbacks, Williams demonstrates top tier potential and has shown flashes of elite cover skills. His consistency remains something to monitor going forward.

Honorable Mentions: Several other players from the 2019 draft deserve recognition, including Parris Campbell (WR), Noah Fant (TE), and Jawaan Taylor (OT). Their contributions have been significant but not quite enough to crack the top 10.

Lessons Learned:

The 2019 draft highlights the unpredictable nature of the NFL. While some players like Nick Bosa met expectations, others exceeded them, showcasing the importance of player development and scheme fit. This draft's success and failures offer valuable insights for future NFL scouting and drafting strategies. Evaluating talent remains an inexact science, but careful analysis and long-term projections are crucial.

What about the Busts? Not all picks from the 2019 draft have been successful. Analyzing those who didn't live up to their potential offers equally valuable lessons for front offices around the league. This could be a topic for a future article.

Call to Action: What are your thoughts on this top 10 list? Share your opinions and who you would include or exclude in the comments below!