Evaluating Backup Quarterbacks: Who Could Carry An NFL Team To The 2024 Playoffs?

David

3 min read

Post on Sep 05, 2025

4.5

Share

Evaluating Backup Quarterbacks: Who Could Carry an NFL Team to the 2024 Playoffs?

The NFL is a league of unpredictable twists and turns. One devastating injury to a star quarterback can completely derail a season, transforming playoff contenders into also-rans. That's why the quality of a team's backup quarterback is arguably more crucial than ever. But which backups possess the talent and experience to not just fill in, but actually lead their team to the 2024 playoffs? Let's delve into the contenders.

The Top Tier: Proven Commodities

Several backups stand out as having demonstrated the ability to perform at a high level when called upon. These quarterbacks aren't just clipboard holders; they've seen significant game action and delivered.

• Brock Purdy (San Francisco 49ers): Purdy's late-season surge in 2022, culminating in a dominant playoff run before injury, catapulted him into the spotlight. His quick release, accurate arm, and surprisingly resilient play style make him a viable starter. The question remains: can he stay healthy? His recovery from elbow surgery will be key to his – and the 49ers’ – success.

• Cooper Rush (Dallas Cowboys): A consistent performer when thrust into action, Rush has repeatedly showcased his ability to manage games and avoid costly turnovers. While not a flashy playmaker, his steady hand and understanding of the Cowboys' system make him a valuable asset. His experience within the Cowboys' offensive scheme is a significant advantage.

• Taylor Heinicke (Atlanta Falcons): Heinicke's experience as a starting quarterback gives him a considerable edge. His scrambles and ability to extend plays can be effective against aggressive defenses, a key skill for a backup. He’s shown the ability to lead a team to wins, proving his value beyond just game management.

The Rising Stars: Potential Playoff Performers

Beyond the proven veterans, a few younger quarterbacks possess the potential to surprise and lead their teams to unexpected success.

• Malik Willis (Tennessee Titans): Willis needs more seasoning, but his incredible athleticism and arm talent could make him a dangerous weapon. A full offseason as the primary backup, learning from Ryan Tannehill, could be pivotal to his development. His ceiling is high, but consistency is the key to reaching it.

The Wildcards: Untested but Intriguing

Several teams boast backups with limited NFL experience, yet their potential can’t be ignored.

• Sean Clifford (Green Bay Packers): Clifford’s college experience suggests he has the talent to potentially perform well if given the opportunity. However, his transition to the NFL will be crucial, needing time to adjust and prove he's ready for a potential starting role. His performance in the preseason will be heavily scrutinized.

Factors Beyond Talent: Coaching and Team Support

It’s crucial to remember that a quarterback's success isn't solely dependent on individual talent. A strong supporting cast, a well-coached offensive line, and a reliable running game are all vital components for any team aiming for the playoffs. Even the most talented backup will struggle without these crucial elements.

Conclusion: The Road to the Playoffs is Uncertain

Predicting which backup quarterback will lead their team to the 2024 playoffs is inherently difficult. While some possess proven track records and superior talent, the unexpected nature of injuries and in-season developments adds a layer of unpredictability. However, the quarterbacks highlighted above certainly present the most promising cases of backups with the potential to carry their teams to postseason success. Only time will tell who rises to the occasion. Keep your eye on these players throughout the upcoming season.

Call to Action: Who do you think has the best chance of leading their team to the playoffs? Share your predictions in the comments below!