Evaluating Backup Quarterbacks: 2024 NFL Playoff Contenders And Underdogs.

David

3 min read

Post on Jun 21, 2025

4.7

Share

Evaluating Backup Quarterbacks: 2024 NFL Playoff Contenders and Underdogs

The NFL season is a marathon, not a sprint, and even the most seasoned starting quarterbacks are susceptible to injury. This makes the quality of a team's backup quarterback a critical factor in determining playoff success – or failure. While star power grabs headlines, a reliable second-stringer can be the difference between a Super Bowl run and an early exit. Let's dive into the backup quarterback situations of some 2024 NFL playoff contenders and underdogs, analyzing their strengths and weaknesses.

Contenders with Solid Backup Options:

Several teams heading into the 2024 season boast backup quarterbacks capable of stepping in and keeping the team competitive. These teams are better positioned to weather the storm of a starting quarterback injury.

• Kansas City Chiefs: While Patrick Mahomes is arguably the league's best, the Chiefs have a capable backup in Blaine Gabbert. His experience and familiarity with Andy Reid's system provide a degree of comfort. This stability is crucial for a team aiming for another Super Bowl appearance.

• Philadelphia Eagles: Jalen Hurts' health is paramount for the Eagles' success. However, they have a solid backup plan in Marcus Mariota, a veteran with starting experience. Mariota’s mobility and familiarity with NFL offenses offer a level of insurance that many teams lack.

• Buffalo Bills: Josh Allen’s incredible talent makes him a central figure for Buffalo. However, the Bills' backup situation is a significant point of consideration. While not possessing a veteran with extensive starting experience like other contenders, the Bills are likely to invest in a more experienced QB2 during the offseason to address this potential weakness.

Underdogs with Questionable Backup Situations:

Conversely, several teams considered playoff underdogs face significant questions at the backup quarterback position. A starting quarterback injury could severely derail their postseason hopes.

• New York Jets: Aaron Rodgers' arrival elevates the Jets significantly, but their backup situation remains a concern. The Jets lack a proven, experienced backup who can consistently perform at a high level. This vulnerability could significantly impact their playoff aspirations.

• Dallas Cowboys: Dak Prescott's injury history is a factor. While Cooper Rush has proven to be a capable game manager in limited appearances, he isn't a quarterback who can carry a team to the playoffs consistently. The Cowboys need to address this concern to maintain competitiveness.

• Baltimore Ravens: Lamar Jackson's unique skillset makes him vital to the Ravens. But, their backup quarterback situation needs serious attention. Finding a backup who can effectively run the offense and maintain the team's identity is a crucial offseason priority.

H2: The Importance of Backup QB Experience and System Familiarity

The value of a backup quarterback extends beyond simply filling in. Experience and familiarity with the team's offensive system are critical factors. A veteran backup who understands the playbook and can lead the offense effectively minimizes disruption in the event of an injury. Conversely, an inexperienced backup can lead to inconsistent play and a significant drop-off in offensive production.

H2: Offseason Moves to Watch:

Many teams will likely address their backup quarterback situation during the off-season. Free agency and the NFL Draft will be key areas to watch for teams looking to upgrade their depth at the position. Expect to see a flurry of moves as teams prioritize securing a reliable backup before the next season begins.

Conclusion:

The role of the backup quarterback is often overlooked, but it's a critical component of any team's success. Teams with experienced and capable backups are better positioned to navigate the challenges of a long NFL season and potentially reach the playoffs. Those with question marks at this position could see their season end prematurely. Keep an eye on how teams address this vital position during the upcoming offseason, as it could significantly influence the 2024 NFL playoff race.