Evaluating Backup QBs: Who's Got The Stuff For A 2024 NFL Playoff Contender?

David

3 min read

Post on Jun 08, 2025

4.5

Share

Evaluating Backup QBs: Who's Got the Stuff for a 2024 NFL Playoff Contender?

The NFL is a brutal league, where even the most seasoned quarterbacks are susceptible to injury. That's why having a capable backup is crucial for any team harboring Super Bowl aspirations. But separating the potential playoff saviors from the clipboard-dwellers is a complex task. Let's dive into the quarterback depth charts and evaluate some of the backups poised to potentially carry a team in 2024.

The Top Tier: Proven Commodities

Several teams boast backups with starting experience and proven success. These aren't just emergency options; they're legitimate threats to lead a playoff run.

• Brock Purdy (San Francisco 49ers): While his 2023 season ended prematurely due to injury, Purdy's late-season surge showed remarkable poise and skill. His ability to manage the 49ers' complex offense and make crucial throws under pressure makes him a valuable asset. The question is his health and ability to fully recover from his elbow surgery.

• Cooper Rush (Dallas Cowboys): Rush has consistently demonstrated reliability when called upon, filling in admirably for Dak Prescott. While not a flashy player, his game management skills and experience within the Cowboys' system make him a dependable option should Prescott falter.

• Gardner Minshew (Indianapolis Colts): A fan favorite with a unique personality, Minshew has shown moments of brilliance throughout his career. He might not be a long-term solution but his experience and adaptability could be huge for the Colts in a pinch.

The Mid-Tier: Potential Dark Horses

This group possesses potential but needs to prove their readiness for primetime. These backups could surprise and elevate their teams to unexpected heights, but they also carry more risk.

• Will Grier (Dallas Cowboys): Grier has yet to truly show his potential on the NFL stage. While he has talent and was drafted in 2019, an injury-marred career has limited his playing time. This season will be a big test for him.

• Bailey Zappe (New England Patriots): Zappe showed flashes of brilliance in his limited action in 2022. His arm strength and accuracy are promising, but he needs consistent playing time to hone his skills and develop into a reliable starter. The Patriots’ coaching staff's assessment of his development will be key.

The Bottom Tier: High Risk, High Reward (or Not)

These backups are mostly untested and represent significant question marks for their respective teams. Their performance would depend heavily on factors outside their direct control.

• Many teams rely on young, inexperienced quarterbacks or those with limited NFL experience to fill their backup roles. These players are generally high-risk propositions that teams may consider upgrading this offseason.

Beyond the Names: What Makes a Great Backup?

It's not just about raw talent; several key attributes distinguish elite backup quarterbacks:

• System Mastery: Understanding the offensive scheme is paramount. A quick study can seamlessly integrate into the game plan, minimizing disruption.
• Game Management: Avoiding crucial mistakes is critical. A backup QB doesn't need to be a gunslinger; steady play under pressure is paramount.
• Experience: While not always necessary, prior starting experience can make a huge difference in handling the pressure of a high-stakes situation.

Conclusion: The 2024 Playoff Picture Hinges on Depth

The quest for Super Bowl glory often depends on factors beyond a team's star players. A dependable backup quarterback is a crucial piece of the puzzle. While some backups are safer bets than others, the upcoming season will reveal which quarterbacks possess the mettle to lead their teams to a deep playoff run. Stay tuned to see who rises to the occasion and who falls short. Who do you think will be the unsung hero of the 2024 NFL playoffs? Let us know in the comments!