Dolphins' Hill Reveals Top 5 NFL Quarterbacks; Tua Left Out

David

3 min read

Post on May 08, 2025

4.6

Share

Dolphins' Hill Reveals Top 5 NFL Quarterbacks; Tua's Absence Sparks Debate

Miami Dolphins cornerback, Xavien Howard, recently stirred the pot by revealing his personal top 5 NFL quarterbacks, notably omitting his own teammate, Tua Tagovailoa. This surprising revelation has ignited a fiery debate among NFL fans and analysts, prompting discussions about Tua's performance and the subjective nature of quarterback rankings.

The NFL is a league of opinions, and few things ignite debate quite like ranking quarterbacks. Xavien Howard, known for his lockdown defense on the field, recently shared his personal top five quarterbacks, a list that conspicuously left out his Dolphins teammate, Tua Tagovailoa. This has sent ripples through the NFL community, prompting questions about Howard's criteria and sparking a larger conversation about Tua's place among the league's elite.

Howard's list, shared via social media, quickly went viral. While he didn't elaborate on his reasoning, the omission of Tua, a quarterback who has shown flashes of brilliance but also battled injuries, has fueled speculation. The selection itself, however, offers a fascinating glimpse into how even those intimately involved in the game perceive quarterback talent.

<h3>Howard's Top 5 (Unofficial):</h3>

While the exact order remains unconfirmed by Howard himself, various sources reported the following players in his top 5:

1. Patrick Mahomes (Kansas City Chiefs): Mahomes' consistent brilliance and Super Bowl victory solidify his place at the top for many. His improvisational skills and pinpoint accuracy make him a perennial MVP candidate.
2. Josh Allen (Buffalo Bills): Allen's combination of arm strength, mobility, and leadership has established him as one of the NFL's most dynamic quarterbacks. His playoff performances have only added to his growing reputation.
3. Joe Burrow (Cincinnati Bengals): Burrow's composure under pressure and ability to lead his team to consecutive Super Bowls has cemented his status as a top quarterback. His strong arm and sharp decision-making are key elements of his success.
4. Jalen Hurts (Philadelphia Eagles): Hurts' dual-threat abilities and Super Bowl appearance speak volumes. His running ability and improved passing accuracy have made him a force to be reckoned with.
5. Justin Herbert (Los Angeles Chargers): Herbert's arm talent and consistent high-level play have made him a fan favorite and a leader for the Chargers. His potential remains incredibly high.

<h3>The Tua Tagovailoa Question:</h3>

The glaring absence of Tua Tagovailoa from Howard's list is the most discussed aspect of this revelation. Tagovailoa has shown significant potential, leading the Dolphins to the playoffs and showcasing impressive arm talent and accuracy. However, concerns remain regarding his durability and consistency. His injury history is undoubtedly a factor considered by many, including potentially Howard.

Is this a fair assessment? The debate rages on. Some argue Howard's list reflects a subjective opinion based on personal observation and playing against these quarterbacks. Others point to Tua's undeniable talent and potential, suggesting his exclusion is premature. The discussion highlights the complexities of evaluating quarterbacks, where statistics often don't tell the whole story.

<h3>The Subjectivity of NFL Rankings:</h3>

Ultimately, ranking NFL quarterbacks is a highly subjective endeavor. Different analysts and fans will weigh various factors differently – statistics, playoff success, leadership qualities, and even intangible factors like "clutch performance." Howard's list serves as a reminder of this subjectivity and the ongoing evolution of player assessments.

What are your thoughts? Do you agree with Howard's top 5? Share your own ranking in the comments below!