Dolphins' Hill Reveals Top 5 NFL Quarterbacks; Tua Excluded

David

3 min read

Post on May 08, 2025

4.2

Share

Dolphins' Hill Reveals Top 5 NFL Quarterbacks; Tua's Omission Sparks Debate

Miami, FL – A bombshell dropped in the NFL world this week, not from a game-winning touchdown or a blockbuster trade, but from the surprisingly outspoken mouth of Miami Dolphins cornerback, Xavien Howard. In a recent interview, Howard boldly declared his top five NFL quarterbacks, notably excluding Miami Dolphins star quarterback, Tua Tagovailoa. This omission has ignited a fiery debate among fans and analysts alike, questioning Howard's judgment and reigniting the ongoing discussion surrounding Tagovailoa's potential.

Howard's list, revealed during a podcast appearance, sparked immediate controversy. He cited several factors influencing his rankings, including accuracy, arm strength, and leadership qualities. While he praised Tagovailoa's talent, he ultimately left him off the list, citing a lack of consistent elite performance compared to his top choices. The fallout? A social media frenzy and a flurry of hot takes from sports pundits.

<h3>Howard's Top 5 (and the Rationale)</h3>

Howard’s controversial top 5 list, presented without ranking order, included:

• Patrick Mahomes (Kansas City Chiefs): A universally acclaimed choice, Mahomes' consistent Super Bowl contention and breathtaking plays solidified his place in Howard's eyes. His improvisational skills and undeniable arm talent are frequently lauded.

• Josh Allen (Buffalo Bills): Allen’s powerful arm and ability to extend plays, often resulting in spectacular touchdowns, made him a clear contender for Howard. His combination of size and athleticism makes him a unique challenge for defensive players.

• Joe Burrow (Cincinnati Bengals): Burrow's composure under pressure and his accuracy are traits that clearly impressed Howard. His leadership and ability to guide the Bengals to the Super Bowl earned him a spot in the top five.

• Justin Herbert (Los Angeles Chargers): Herbert’s raw talent and prolific passing ability are undeniable. Howard likely appreciated his cannon of an arm and the potential for big plays.

• Aaron Rodgers (New York Jets): A veteran with a proven track record of success, Rodgers’ experience and precision clearly resonated with Howard. His ability to read defenses and make timely throws are hallmarks of his career.

<h3>The Tua Tagovailoa Question</h3>

Tagovailoa's exclusion is the most contentious aspect of Howard's list. While he acknowledged Tagovailoa's talent, he pointed to inconsistency as a key factor in his decision. This criticism highlights a common concern among some fans and analysts. While Tagovailoa has shown flashes of brilliance, injuries and occasional inconsistencies have prevented him from consistently achieving top-tier quarterback status.

This raises a crucial question: Is Howard's assessment fair? Many argue that Tagovailoa's performance has been hampered by factors beyond his control, particularly injuries. Others maintain that his inconsistency is a valid concern, regardless of external factors. The debate continues.

<h3>The Bigger Picture: Perspective and Context</h3>

It’s important to remember that Howard's list is subjective. It reflects his perspective as a cornerback, focusing on what he sees on the field against these quarterbacks. His list isn't an objective ranking of all NFL quarterbacks, and it doesn't diminish Tagovailoa's considerable accomplishments. It simply provides a compelling talking point for fans and analysts to engage with. Ultimately, whether you agree with Howard or not, it's clear that the NFL quarterback landscape remains fiercely competitive and incredibly exciting.

What are your thoughts? Who would be your top five NFL quarterbacks? Let us know in the comments below!