Dolphins' Hill Reveals Top 5 NFL Quarterbacks, Leaving Out Tua

David

3 min read

Post on May 08, 2025

4.6

Share

Dolphins' Hill Snubs Tua: Top 5 NFL Quarterbacks Revealed, Igniting Heated Debate

The NFL offseason is always a whirlwind of speculation, trades, and rankings. But this year, a seemingly innocuous list from Miami Dolphins cornerback Xavien Howard has sparked a firestorm of debate among fans and analysts alike. Howard, known for his hard-hitting style on the field, recently revealed his personal top 5 NFL quarterbacks – and notably absent from the list was his own teammate, Tua Tagovailoa. This omission has ignited a heated discussion about Tua's potential, the subjective nature of quarterback rankings, and the intense pressures within the NFL.

Howard's Controversial Top 5:

While Howard hasn't publicly elaborated on his reasoning, his top 5, as reported by various sports outlets, is causing quite a stir. The exact order varies slightly depending on the source, but the players consistently named include:

• Patrick Mahomes (Kansas City Chiefs): Undeniably a top contender, Mahomes' consistent performance and Super Bowl victory cement his place among the elite.
• Josh Allen (Buffalo Bills): Known for his powerful arm and athleticism, Allen's impressive statistics and playoff appearances make him a perennial top-five quarterback.
• Joe Burrow (Cincinnati Bengals): Burrow's leadership and Super Bowl appearance quickly established him as a top quarterback in the league. His consistent performance and clutch plays solidify his position.
• Justin Herbert (Los Angeles Chargers): Herbert's exceptional talent and strong arm have made him a fan favorite and a consistent threat in the AFC.
• Jalen Hurts (Philadelphia Eagles): Hurts' performance in Super Bowl LVII, combined with his consistent regular season success, has solidified his position among the top quarterbacks.

The Tua Tagovailoa Question:

The glaring absence of Tua Tagovailoa from Howard's list is what's truly fueling the conversation. Tagovailoa, despite showing flashes of brilliance and leading the Dolphins to the playoffs, has also faced criticism regarding his consistency and injury history. This raises the question: is Howard's ranking purely based on performance, or are other factors, such as perceived durability or leadership qualities, influencing his decision?

Some argue that Howard's list reflects a fair assessment of current NFL quarterback dominance. Others believe it's a premature judgment, given Tagovailoa's potential and relatively young age. The debate highlights the difficulty of objectively ranking quarterbacks, a task often influenced by personal biases and recent performance.

The Subjectivity of NFL Rankings:

It's important to remember that any quarterback ranking is inherently subjective. Different analysts and fans will prioritize different skills and metrics. While statistics like passer rating and touchdowns are valuable, they don't fully capture the nuances of quarterback play, such as leadership, decision-making under pressure, and overall team impact.

Ultimately, Howard's top 5 list serves as a reminder that the NFL is a constantly evolving landscape, with quarterbacks vying for dominance and opinions constantly shifting. While Tua's exclusion is controversial, it ignites a productive conversation about the challenges of evaluating quarterback talent and the intense pressure players face in a highly competitive league.

What are your thoughts? Share your top 5 NFL quarterbacks in the comments below!