Debating The Issues In Ari Aster's "Eddington": A Cinematic Discussion

David

3 min read

Post on Jul 21, 2025

4.3

Share

Debating the Issues in Ari Aster's "Midsommar" and "Hereditary": A Cinematic Discussion

Ari Aster has rapidly become one of the most discussed names in modern horror. His films, Hereditary (2018) and Midsommar (2019), aren't just jump-scare fests; they're deeply unsettling explorations of grief, trauma, and family dynamics, sparking heated debates among critics and audiences alike. This article delves into the key themes and interpretations surrounding these two unsettling masterpieces, examining their impact and legacy within the horror genre.

The Unraveling Family: Exploring Grief and Trauma in Hereditary

Hereditary, with its slow-burn tension and shocking revelations, introduced Aster's signature style: a chilling blend of psychological horror and familial dysfunction. The film masterfully depicts the devastating impact of grief on the Graham family following the death of their matriarch. This grief is not neatly packaged; instead, it morphs into paranoia, suspicion, and ultimately, unimaginable horror.

• Grief's Unpredictable Nature: The film doesn't shy away from showcasing the messy, chaotic nature of grief. Annie Graham's (Toni Collette's Oscar-worthy performance) descent into madness is both terrifying and relatable, highlighting the unpredictable and often destructive power of unresolved trauma.
• Inherited Trauma: The film’s title itself hints at the central theme: inherited trauma. The family's history is slowly revealed, uncovering a disturbing lineage of occult practices and the devastating consequences of intergenerational trauma.
• Cult Dynamics and Manipulation: The film subtly introduces the elements of a sinister cult, showcasing the insidious nature of manipulation and the ease with which vulnerable individuals can be drawn into destructive practices.

Sunlight and Shadows: Examining Pagan Rituals and Female Agency in Midsommar

Midsommar, while sharing thematic similarities with Hereditary, offers a different visual and narrative approach. Set in the idyllic Swedish countryside, the film initially presents a deceptive sense of peace before descending into a nightmarish exploration of pagan rituals and the complexities of female relationships.

• Folk Horror and its Modern Relevance: The film's use of folk horror tropes resonates deeply with contemporary anxieties surrounding community, tradition, and the suppression of female voices.
• Toxic Relationships and Female Empowerment (or Lack Thereof): Dani's (Florence Pugh's compelling performance) journey is a complex one, navigating a devastating loss and a dysfunctional relationship. The film explores whether her experience in the Harga commune constitutes empowerment or simply a shift in the dynamics of control.
• The Power of Visual Storytelling: Midsommar's vibrant cinematography, in stark contrast to Hereditary's darkness, is a powerful tool used to subvert expectations and create a sense of unease. The bright sunlight ironically intensifies the horror unfolding.

Comparing and Contrasting Aster's Vision:

While both films explore themes of family, grief, and the supernatural, their approaches differ significantly. Hereditary is a claustrophobic descent into darkness, while Midsommar utilizes a deceptive idyllic setting to mask its unsettling rituals. However, both films share Aster's meticulous attention to detail, creating rich and disturbing cinematic experiences that linger long after the credits roll.

The Lasting Impact:

Ari Aster's films have undeniably left a mark on the horror genre, pushing boundaries and challenging audiences to confront uncomfortable truths about grief, trauma, and the human condition. The ongoing discussions surrounding his work solidify his position as a significant voice in modern cinema, prompting further analysis and appreciation of his unique vision.

Further Reading:

• [Link to a critical analysis of Hereditary]
• [Link to an article discussing the folk horror genre]
• [Link to an interview with Ari Aster]

This article aims to spark further discussion. What are your interpretations of Ari Aster's work? Share your thoughts in the comments below!