Could A Backup QB Lead An NFL Team To The 2024 Playoffs? Our Rankings.

David

3 min read

Post on May 16, 2025

4.3

Share

Could a Backup QB Lead an NFL Team to the 2024 Playoffs? Our Rankings.

The NFL is a league of unpredictable twists and turns. One minute, a star quarterback is leading their team to victory; the next, they're sidelined with an injury, leaving their fate in the hands of a backup. This begs the crucial question: could a backup quarterback realistically lead an NFL team to the playoffs in 2024? The answer, surprisingly, is a complex "maybe," depending on several factors. We've ranked the teams and backup quarterbacks most likely to pull off this remarkable feat.

The Crucial Ingredients: More Than Just Arm Strength

While a strong arm is essential, a backup quarterback needs more than just talent to lead a playoff push. Several factors contribute to their potential success:

• Offensive Line Prowess: A strong offensive line is crucial for any quarterback, but especially for a backup stepping into a high-pressure situation. They need time in the pocket to make reads and deliver accurate passes.
• A Strong Running Game: A robust running game takes pressure off the quarterback, allowing them to manage the game effectively and avoid risky throws.
• A Talented Receiving Corps: Reliable receivers who can make contested catches and move the chains are indispensable for any quarterback, especially one lacking experience in a starting role.
• Coaching Staff Expertise: A skilled coaching staff can adapt the offensive game plan to suit the backup's strengths and minimize their weaknesses.
• Team Chemistry and Momentum: A team's overall chemistry and existing momentum before the starter's injury significantly influence the backup's chances of success.

Our Rankings: Contenders and Long Shots

Based on these factors, we've ranked NFL teams with the highest likelihood of a backup quarterback leading them to the 2024 playoffs:

Tier 1: Realistically Possible

1. Philadelphia Eagles: Jalen Hurts' injury history makes this a realistic scenario. Their strong offensive line, running game, and receiving corps give their backup a fighting chance. [Link to Eagles Roster]
2. Kansas City Chiefs: While Patrick Mahomes' durability is generally high, the Chiefs' supporting cast is arguably the best in the league, potentially masking any backup quarterback's weaknesses. [Link to Chiefs Roster]
3. Buffalo Bills: Josh Allen's injury history, coupled with the Bills' overall strong team, makes them a dark horse contender if Allen were to miss significant time. [Link to Bills Roster]

Tier 2: Possible, But Unlikely

4. Dallas Cowboys: The Cowboys have a talented roster, but their playoff success hinges heavily on Dak Prescott's health. Their backup would face a steeper climb. [Link to Cowboys Roster]
5. Cincinnati Bengals: Joe Burrow's health is paramount to the Bengals' success. Their backup quarterback would need to significantly outperform expectations to propel them to the playoffs. [Link to Bengals Roster]

Tier 3: Long Shots

Teams in this tier lack the overall roster strength or have significant question marks at key positions to support a backup quarterback adequately.

Factors Affecting the Odds:

The length of the starting quarterback's injury is a significant factor. A short-term absence is far different from a season-ending injury. Furthermore, the backup quarterback's individual skillset and experience will greatly influence their potential. Some backups have proven themselves capable of starting roles, while others may struggle under the intense pressure of the NFL.

Conclusion:

While unlikely, a backup quarterback leading an NFL team to the playoffs in 2024 is not entirely improbable. The teams in Tier 1 possess the necessary supporting cast to potentially overcome a starting quarterback's injury. However, much depends on various factors, including the quality of the backup quarterback, the length of the injury, and the team's overall performance. The 2024 season promises to be exciting, with plenty of potential for unexpected twists and turns. Stay tuned!

Call to Action: What do you think? Which team's backup quarterback has the best chance of leading their team to the playoffs? Share your predictions in the comments below!